Can Exchange Rates Rocky Terrain Leads to Growth, Instability?

Aug 3 , 2024
By Mushe Semu

---

The recent macroeconomic overhaul in a country experiencing economic development and diplomatic pressure has ignited a firestorm of controversy. Advocates argue that the policy could usher in growth and development, while critics caution against possible serious pitfalls. Given the high stakes, it is crucial to unpack the potential implications for Ethiopia's economy and its citizens.

The government lauds the proposed policy's merits, yet critics note a lack of thorough consideration of potential downsides. They warn that any policy enacted by executive order could ricochet, fueling chronic economic instability, a predicament that requires a careful evaluation of near-term effects.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF), in its research published in "Financial Development," warns that while floating exchange rates may address overvaluation risks, they do not necessarily guarantee low inflation, diminished volatility, or enhanced trade integration, compared with fixed exchange-rate regimes.

Comparative analysis reveals a mixed bag. Context is king, as each country’s unique economic milieu has influenced the outcomes.

Countries like Spain, Greece, Iceland, and Poland have had inconsistent results with floating exchange rates. China's strategic approach of managing an exchange rate to boost exports is evident in the notion that prudent management, not full-blown liberalisation, can produce higher economic results.

A case in point is Singapore, a country with a positive trade balance, that has chosen a managed floating policy, facilitating regulated fluctuation within stipulated limits.

In contrast, Ethiopia’s considerable trade deficit demands a more cautious approach.

Despite the potential benefit of exchange rate liberalisation, Ethiopia’s complexities demand careful consideration of associated risks. A completely liberalised exchange rate could trigger uncertain economic outcomes, with considerable risks of inflation bursts, currency value instability, and a hit to overall economic productivity.

For a country like Ethiopia, struggling with high demand and supply shortages, a system based on a free-floating exchange rate could invite erratic currency fluctuations. This unpredictability could make it harder to forecast economic trajectory, thereby pouring cold water on investor confidence.

Another looming concern should be Ethiopia's depleted foreign currency reserves. Leaning heavily on market forces to determine exchange rates could further destabilise prices and pose formidable economic challenges.

Devaluation of the Birr could drive up the cost of imports, including essential services and goods. This could fan the flames of inflation, impacting the cost of living and potentially fueling social unrest. Ethiopia's economic productivity is already under duress due to ongoing conflicts that impact exports and overall economic stability. An unrestrained floating exchange rate could potentially exacerbate these issues rather than remedy them.

Policies should strike a balance between short-term pressures and long-term stability, keeping the average Ethiopian economic welfare front and centre. Comprehensive strategies encompassing managed exchange rates and targeted economic reforms could be the key to unlocking sustainable development in Ethiopia.

---

PUBLISHED ON Aug 03,2024 [ VOL 25 , NO 1266]

---