
Jan 3 , 2021
By Clay Webster
Instead of putting in place a complicated initiative by a government or industry association to recycle a greater percentage of the water bottles that are discarded, simply increasing the refund fee for returning collected bottles would do the trick, writes Clay Webster (complaintsandrecriminations@gmail.com), who studied energy and environmental policy at Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies and has written about energy, commodity and financial markets for The Motley Fool, Plattsand US News & World Report.
One of the seemingly unsolvable byproducts of Ethiopia’s surging domestic investment in new water bottling companies is the plethora of discarded plastic bottles that litter roadsides and clog water drainage systems throughout urban areas. Many of these bottles travel out of urban places via waterways and pollute ecosystems further off in rural ones.
This is not an unknown issue. Governmental bodies have sounded the alarm and even put forth new initiatives to fight the scourge. A new group of private bottlers has even formed an association to raise funding for extensive recycling efforts.
But all this harping on solutions to the plastic bottle problem appears to have ignored the most obvious panacea – raising the refund fee for returned bottles.
As current policy stands, informal collectors – normally those unemployed by the formal sector – can stand to make a negligible fee for each kilogram of bottles they turn in to recycling centres. This policy allows for a certain amount of cleanup to happen naturally.
But as any observer can note on their own, there remains a surplus of uncollected bottles that make their way into rural areas far from recycling companies. These bottles either remain in the environment and leach chemical residue into the soil and waterways for centuries or make their way into landfills.
On the commercial side of things, recycling plastic bottles domestically also saves foreign currency that would otherwise be required to import the necessary petrochemicals.
Rather than concocting some government or industry initiative to recycle a slightly greater percentage of the total bottles, simply increasing the refund fee for returning collected bottles would do the trick all by itself. By adding a one or two Birr surtax to the retail price that would then go to pay for each bottle returned, a circular economy would be created wherein collecting bottles for a living would pay off handsomely.
A greater number of collectors would join the informal economy, driving down the number of discarded bottles, and the increased refund fee would compensate longer transport distances for returning the bottles to recycling facilities from rural communities. Additionally, an increased refund fee would flow to the income of informal collectors, most of whom make up the ranks of the unemployed poor. In this sense, the policy would double as an anti-poverty programme without costing the government budget any additional funds.
Of course, the water bottlers would likely lobby against such a tax, which would raise retail prices by 10 to 15pc. But the theory behind this type of tax system is nothing new.
British economist Arthur Pigou came up with his namesake Pigouvian tax a century ago. The reasoning behind them is that since commercial activities have always produced external costs on those other than the purchaser of certain goods, those costs must be added back in through tax policy to be paid by the buyer of the good.
In the present situation, the buyer of bottled water may discard the bottle in the environment once she is finished drinking it. The bottle costs present and future generations in terms of its ongoing pollution even though they did not benefit from drinking it. By placing the cost of pollution on the front-end user, Pigouvian taxes forces users to pre-pay for the future costs of their purchase.
Nations with this type of deposit refund scheme recycled between 80pc and 95pc of their plastic bottles, much higher than those without it, according to research by the UK Parliament’s Environmental Audit Committee in 2017.
But the refund amount is just as important. By increasing the recycled portion of the more than one billion plastic bottles that are produced here every year, Ethiopia will benefit from less plastic pollution, increase the incomes of the poor, and save scarce foreign currency for greater needs.
PUBLISHED ON
Jan 03,2021 [ VOL
21 , NO
1079]
My Opinion | Jan 07,2024
Commentaries | Jul 15,2023
Editorial | Sep 24,2022
Commentaries | Sep 03,2022
Editorial | Dec 19,2021
My Opinion | 126776 Views | Aug 14,2021
My Opinion | 122900 Views | Aug 21,2021
My Opinion | 121057 Views | Sep 10,2021
My Opinion | 118956 Views | Aug 07,2021
Dec 22 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Charged with transforming colossal state-owned enterprises into modern and competitiv...
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 28 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Unhabitual, perhaps too many, Samuel Gebreyohannes, 38, used to occasionally enjoy a couple of beers at breakfast. However, he recently swit...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transporting commodities, and f...
Mar 30 , 2025
When the private satellite channel, Ethiopian Broadcasting Service (EBS), aired an em...
Mar 23 , 2025
Getachew Redda, head of the Tigray Interim Regional Administration (TIRA), at least u...
Mar 16 , 2025
Ask anyone about the population of Addis Abeba, and a straightforward answer proves e...
Mar 9 , 2025
Five years ago, 11 non-governmental organisations (NGOs), together with 40 allies acr...
Mar 30 , 2025
The brewing industry faces a storm, with barley shortages leading to a substantial sp...
Mar 30 , 2025 . By BEZAWIT HULUAGER
Federal officials are accelerating the shift towards domestically assembled electric...
Mar 30 , 2025 . By AKSAH ITALO
The federal government is pushing towards a single account for the treasury to consol...
Mar 30 , 2025 . By BEZAWIT HULUAGER
The Ministry of Transport & Logistics faced scrutiny after federal auditors uncov...