
Fortune News | Mar 03,2020
Mar 7 , 2020
By Dejen Yemane
It has been nine years since Ethiopia launched the construction of its giant hydro-electric dam on the Blue Nile River. Downstream nations' demurral begun in the same year. Many unsuccessful negotiations have taken place in the course of the Dam's construction, but the United States' recent intervention gives a new but deadlocked shape to the endless dispute over the Blue Nile River.
Egyptâs strategy, from A to Z, has been to block any attempt by Ethiopia to have more control over the flow of the Blue Nile waters. This old-fashioned but nuanced position of Egypt escalates the dispute among the African nations. There should be a responsible approach in handling the dispute, which is dropping such obsolete bargaining positions on Egyptâs side and using amicable dispute resolution mechanisms without having to take the matter outside of Africa.
A careful examination of the trajectory of the talks over the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) makes it obvious that the real causes for the dispute are political, rather than scientific or legal. The latter two are camouflage for the centrepiece of the dispute. There is an absence of evidence demonstrating that filling the reservoir would appreciably harm the flow of the Nile, despite Egyptâs intractability toward these facts. Existing legal principles are more than enough to guarantee Egyptâs water use rights from the Blue Nile River.
The secret behind Egyptâs intransigence lies in the preservation of the status quo of the water use and continuance of hydro hegemony in the Nile Basin. This position has been evident ever since the start of the negotiations. There has been no attempt to drop the sentiment of hegemony even in the presence of concessions from Ethiopiaâs side. Ethiopiaâs concession thus gives leeway to Egypt to enlarge its demands in the process of the negotiations.
In the situation where Ethiopia has taken all necessary steps before starting its first filling, as provided by the 2015 Declaration of Principles, Egyptâs appeal to Americaâs mediation was bizarre. The North African country is using this strategy as a last ditch effort to reaffirm its colonial-era water appropriation rights, which will remain a pipedream if Ethiopia holds firm.
Egyptâs determination to maintain its hydro hegemony over the Nile River has led to this unnecessary diplomatic stalemate, bringing the US on board the Nile dispute.
The United Statesâ participation in the Blue Nile saga was viewed with scepticism from the beginning. The shifting roles played by the country in the negotiations reveal its partisanship toward Egypt. It is no longer an observer, as was stated earlier, but has begun drafting the terms of the agreement.
The reason President Donald Trumpâs administration wishes to give Egypt the advantage has largely been seen as a quid pro quo to get the Egyptians onboard with the USâ Middle East peace plan. Trump is eager to take the credit by pushing the states to sign the deal, according to observers. Hence, Ethiopiaâs interests appear to be counterproductive to Americaâs interests. Ethiopia is unwilling to accept the draft agreement prepared by America due to its scope and unbalanced nature.
The recent statement made by the US Treasury Department blatantly shows Americaâs partisanship toward Egypt. Ethiopia rejected the statement outright and the US seems to have hit a wall at the moment. Ethiopia will not go to Washington to discuss the deal prepared by the US. The negotiation, however, may be continued among the three nations if Sudan and Egypt accept Ethiopiaâs call for a continuation of the talks.
It has been all the more interesting that Americaâs statement was coincidentally published on the eve of the 124th commemoration of the Adwa victory, the date when Ethiopia's forefathers paid a matchless price for this country's sovereignty. The public uttered its regrets when it saw that the US had struck a blow to our sense of independence.
âFinal testing and fillings should not take place without an agreement,â said the USâ statement.
Social media platforms were awash with patriotic sentiments, calling for the US to cease pressuring Ethiopia over its dam. The US should know that the Blue Nile is our river and that the GERD is our dam.
The Ethiopian government has likewise pushed back, insisting that this was "not the outcome of the negotiation" with Egypt and Sudan that it was looking for. The government also noted its commitment to continuing the negotiations.
On Ethiopiaâs absence from the last round of the Washington talks, Egypt warned that Ethiopia must sign the deal. The country has indicated its determination to use all available means to protect the interests of its people. Such expressions are not new from the Egyptian side, as hawkish rhetoric is not new to Egyptâs leaders in their attempt to maintain their water hegemony.
There are fears that the two nations will go into a conventional war, but its possibility is almost zero. Neither of the two nations will go that far for a dispute that can easily be settled, provided that Egypt drops its insistence on an old-fashioned approach.
If the current government of Egypt is highly concerned about its people and wishes to strike a deal that positively impacts generations, an egotistic approach toward the Blue Nile dispute is neither economical nor sustainable. In a diplomatic era that encourages socio-politically-inspired development and favors countries like Ethiopia, Egypt should be cautious and vigilant.
Todayâs competing interests over the Nile River may not always be officiated around a negotiating table and Ethiopia may not always show this level of patience and cooperation current leaders have shown.
Egypt should be grateful for Ethiopiaâs leniency in the recent talks, which has recently threatened its sovereignty. Ethiopians are furiously blaming their government for its lenient approach. This resistance hints that Ethiopians are determined to stand united in order to ensure their rights to the Blue Nile River.
For a win-win solution, Egypt must drop its old-fashioned position, and any potential deal should be limited to the first filling and annual operation of the GERD. Water allocation in the guise of deciding the filling and operation guidelines is not acceptable and escalates the dispute.
The US-drafted agreement, signed by Egypt, should be forgotten. The Ethiopian government, on the other hand, should be careful in preparing the draft deal on the first filling and annual operation of the GERD. Any unwarranted concession will be rejected outright by the public.
PUBLISHED ON
Mar 07,2020 [ VOL
20 , NO
1036]
Fortune News | Mar 03,2020
Fortune News | Nov 25,2023
Fortune News | Aug 04,2024
Letter To Editor | Feb 29,2020
Fortune News | Oct 26,2019
Radar | Apr 24,2021
Commentaries | Jun 27,2020
Editorial | May 25,2019
Fortune News | Dec 19,2020
Commentaries | Aug 29,2020
My Opinion | 122660 Views | Aug 14,2021
My Opinion | 118775 Views | Aug 21,2021
My Opinion | 117226 Views | Sep 10,2021
My Opinion | 115036 Views | Aug 07,2021
Editorial | Feb 01,2025
Dec 22 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Charged with transforming colossal state-owned enterprises into modern and competitiv...
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 28 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Unhabitual, perhaps too many, Samuel Gebreyohannes, 38, used to occasionally enjoy a couple of beers at breakfast. However, he recently swit...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transporting commodities, and f...
Feb 1 , 2025
Urban renewal is seldom gentle to those on the receiving end of redevelopment. Take s...
Jan 25 , 2025
Grand ambitions have long driven Ethiopia's successive leaders, but they remain weigh...
Jan 18 , 2025
Adanech Abebie, the mayor of Addis Abeba, addressed last week a warm-up session for h...
A severe cash shortage squeezes the economy, and the deposit-to-loan ratio has slumpe...
Feb 1 , 2025
The incumbent Prosperity Party (PP) rallied 1,200 of its ranks amid a turbulent polit...
Feb 2 , 2025 . By AKSAH ITALO
A notable wave of lending rate increases is reshaping the financial sector, following...
Feb 2 , 2025 . By AKSAH ITALO
The coffee industry is reeling after the Ethiopian Coffee & Tea Authority (ECTA)...
Feb 2 , 2025 . By HAGOS GEBREAMLAK
The controversy surrounding the Addis Abeba Chamber of Commerce & Sectoral Associ...