Fortune News | Jul 08,2019
Feb 13 , 2021
By MAYA MISIKIR ( FORTUNE STAFF WRITER )
A local software supplier is at odds with the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia over the evaluation process of two bids floated for the procurement of security software. The supplier, IPXN ICT Consultants & Solution Implementers, has lodged this complaint following the cancellation of a tender for the Privileged Access Management System security software in May 2019 after technical and financial evaluations were finalised.
The Bank cancelled the bid, citing internal reasons to the supplier, which had at the time offered the lowest bid at 460,000 dollars. The second-lowest offer came in at 870,000 dollars by Kenyan-based company Isolution.
Following the cancellation, the bid was refloated a few months later in September 2019 with four companies responding, including IPXN and Isolution. The bid results showed that IPXN had come in second. Isolution had instead offered the lowest price at 850,000 dollars, only 30,000 dollars less than the second-lowest offer.
Isolution, which had come in second during the original bidding process, offered SEED Software, while IPXN offered CyberArk, both products of international security software suppliers.
During the second financial opening, only the summaries of the financial proposals were revealed, according to Abel Challa, managing director at IPXN.
"We requested that the Bank reveal the details of the financial proposals," he said. "We wanted to have clarity on the issue as that had been the procedure during the first bid."
The Bank, in a letter addressed to IPXN, expressed that it could not reveal the details of the financial offer as it was an ongoing issue.
When the final bidder's offer is much higher than the market value, where there is only one bidder that has responded to the call or when readjusting the tender may invite more competitors, bids can be cancelled, according to the Bank's procurement law.
The law also lays the grounds for cancellation where there is evidence of collusion among bidders and where the Bank itself has failed to include a basic requirement in the bid document.
Shortly after the financial proposals were announced, the Bank sent out a letter addressed to SEED IT, requesting that the company make adjustments to details omitted in the financial offer document. The letter from the Bank requested that the provider include details about implementation and training and support maintenance costs, both of which were not included though requested in the bid document.
"We requested a clarification on why the company was being requested to make these adjustments instead of being rejected," said Abel. "We weren't able to get a sufficient response. It has become increasingly difficult to engage in a bid at the Bank if you haven't already been favoured."
Abel states that since then, he had been informed to drop the case by the upper management of the software company, CyberArk, who had gotten wind that he was appealing.
The Bank is at full liberty to cancel the tender as per procurement laws. Still, the principle of transparency dictates that it gives its justification, according to Dilnesahu Samuel, logistics & supply chain management unit head at the School of Commerce at Addis Abeba University.
"Especially in the case where the companies vying for first place switch positions," he said. "A breach of a principle of procurement is a serious issue."
This also brings into play the principle of fair dealing as the companies should be given a level playing field, he added.
While there are grounds for a request for corrections after the submission of a bid, it is restricted to immaterial changes, according to Dilnesahu. Discrepancies between unit price and total price and amounts in words and digits are examples of immaterial errors in which case the law states the former to be given precedence over the latter.
However, material errors, which constitute major errors and include omissions and affect the performance and scope of the offer, are labelled as non-responsive, explained the expert.
"Non-responsive bids are those that don't respond to the specifications and should be rejected," he stated.
Beyond the issues of contractor and supplier, assuring the interest of the public should also be noted, according to the expert.
PUBLISHED ON Feb 13,2021 [ VOL 21 , NO 1085]
Fortune News | Jul 08,2019
Fortune News | Feb 13,2021
Radar | Sep 11,2020
Fortune News | Jun 26,2021
Exclusive Interviews | Jan 05,2020
Fortune News | Aug 03,2019
Radar | May 21,2022
Fortune News | Dec 19,2021
Radar | Feb 04,2023
Radar | Jul 13,2019
Dec 24 , 2022
Biniam Mikru heads the department of cabinet affairs under Mayor Adanech Abiebie. But...
Jul 2 , 2022 . By RUTH TAYE
On a rainy afternoon last week, a coffee processing facility in the capital's Akaki-Qality District was abuzz with activ...
Nov 27 , 2021
Against my will, I have witnessed the most terrible defeat of reason and the most sa...
Nov 13 , 2021
Plans and reality do not always gel. They rarely do in a fast-moving world. Every act...
In the animating landscape of Ethiopia's economic reality, an increasingly fervent tr...
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country's most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or two...
Jun 3 , 2023
At the hub of Ethiopia's fiscal planning on King George VI Street, the country's budg...
May 27 , 2023
Tauted as a somnolent giant, Ethiopia's financial scene now stirs, roused by favourab...
May 20 , 2023
The pungent irony wafting from Pretoria last week was hard to miss. Cyril Ramaphosa,...
May 13 , 2023
In March this year, Kamala Harris, the United States Vice President, visited Ghana, T...
I am acquainted with several young parents who decided to adopt children from non-governmental institutions. The process involved a six-m...
I was in the front seat during a recent car ride and promptly fastened my seatbelt. I unbuckled it upon reaching the destination but th...
Or see contact page