
Viewpoints | Oct 30,2022
Dec 2 , 2023
By Jayati Ghosh
Traditionally intended to protect against asset nationalisation, the investor-state dispute settlement mechanism is increasingly used to challenge government policies that affect corporate profits, writes Jayati Ghosh, a professor of Economics at the University of Massachusetts Amherst and co-chair of the Independent Commission for the Reform of International Corporate Taxation.
Imagine a scenario where a private company effectively creates and controls its own jurisdiction within a sovereign country. This company introduces its own currency, enacts laws, and establishes courts, prisons, police forces, and even intelligence services. It formulates its own tax, labour, and environmental regulations (or lack thereof), regardless of their compatibility with national laws.
Now imagine this company adopting Bitcoin as its official currency and announcing plans to privatise public services. It replaces the existing judicial system with an "arbitration centre" and even introduces a fee-based citizenship model that requires signing a "social contract" designed to encourage good behaviour. Eventually, the country's democratically elected government stops this nonsense and affirms that national laws apply equally to this jurisdiction.
But instead of complying, the company sues the government for billions of dollars, citing its projected financial losses.
This scenario, seemingly lifted straight out of a dystopian novel, is precisely what is happening today in Honduras. The Honduran government is currently contending with seven international investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) claims filed by various private corporations. One US company based in Delaware, Honduras Prospera, is suing the country for a staggering 10.7 billion dollars, representing two-thirds of the government's projected budget for 2023.
The story begins with the 2009 military coup that ousted the democratically elected Honduran President, Manuel Zelaya. Following the coup, the new government quickly enacted a law to establish Special Development Regions with the characteristics described above. In 2012, Honduras's Supreme Court struck down the law, owing to its blatant infringement on Honduran sovereignty. In response, the National Congress impeached several justices and replaced them with more amenable appointees.
This judicial overhaul set the stage for the introduction of the similar Zones for Employment & Economic Development (ZEDE) law in 2013.
Honduras has three ZEDEs: Prospera, Orquidea, and Ciudad Morazan. These entities operate as independent city-states, inspired by the liberation fantasies of billionaire investors like Peter Thiel and Marc Andreessen, who have long dreamed of crypto-based tax havens that flout basic democratic norms. Laws permitting unlimited expansion have facilitated the expropriation of land belonging to residents.
In the Prospera ZEDE, 44pc of the governing authority's members are directly appointed by the corporate owner, and an additional 22pc are elected by landowners whose votes are proportional to the size of their property.
These developments triggered widespread public outrage both within Honduras and around the world. After the leftist Libre party, led by President Xiomara Castro, won the 2021 election, the new administration quickly fulfilled its campaign promise to repeal the ZEDE law, a move that was widely supported by the Honduran public.
But Prospera pushed back, claiming that its agreement with the previous government guaranteed 50 years of legal stability, acknowledged the supremacy of investor rights and privileges, and included "safeguards" under international investment law through the Dominican Republic-Central America Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA-DR) and the United States-Honduras bilateral investment treaty. While Prospera continues to operate St. John's Bay, its "flagship city," the company is seeking compensation from the Honduran government for daring to enforce its own national laws.
Governments, especially in low- and middle-income countries, are understandably wary of ISDS mechanisms that allow foreign investors to seek compensation for policy changes that affect their business. Initially, ISDS was meant to prevent the expropriation of private assets through nationalisation. But, the definition of expropriation has been expanded to such an extent that it can now include any government action that investors believe could negatively affect their profits, such as new regulations and taxes.
When disputes arise, they are resolved through international arbitration tribunals.
There are now several such tribunals, including public ones, such as the World Bank's International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) and the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, and private bodies like the London Court of International Arbitration and the Singapore International Arbitration Centre. But these tribunals overwhelmingly favour investors.
Arbitrators can force governments to pay huge damages, with no legal recourse to appeal decisions. The system is designed to allow corporations to bring claims against states while preventing governments from suing private companies. This apparent bias has prompted some developing countries to withdraw from the ICSID.
The US has played a pivotal (and regrettable) role in establishing this system. In 2020, then-presidential candidate Jeo Biden strongly criticised ISDS, writing, "I don't believe that corporations should get special tribunals that are not available to other organisations." Biden said he opposed "the ability of private corporations to attack labour, health, and environmental policies" through the ISDS process and the "inclusion of such provisions in future trade agreements."
Since then, Biden has honoured his promise to exclude ISDS clauses from future trade agreements. But they still apply to existing treaties like the one currently affecting Honduras.
In May, more than 33 members of Congress, led by Senator Elizabeth Warren and Representative Lloyd Doggett, sent a letter to US Trade Representative Katherine Tai and Secretary of State Antony Blinken, urging them to support Honduras in the ISDS case. But, the Biden Administration has allowed this obscene process to unfold in US courts, even though it contradicts the President's stated position regarding the unjust and undemocratic nature of the ISDS process.
The Honduras ISDS case represents a crucial test for the Biden Administration. Allowing such extreme double standards to prevail, particularly in a matter as clear-cut as this, would irreparably damage any remaining US claim to global leadership.
PUBLISHED ON
Dec 02,2023 [ VOL
24 , NO
1231]
Viewpoints | Oct 30,2022
Radar | Jul 25,2020
Commentaries | Sep 30,2023
My Opinion | Aug 29,2020
Featured | Sep 04,2021
Commentaries | Aug 29,2020
Advertorials | Feb 26,2024
Fortune News | Oct 30,2021
Commentaries | Aug 28,2021
Commentaries | Sep 26,2021
My Opinion | 123331 Views | Aug 14,2021
My Opinion | 119481 Views | Aug 21,2021
My Opinion | 117814 Views | Sep 10,2021
My Opinion | 115665 Views | Aug 07,2021
Sunday with Eden | Feb 16, 2025
Agenda | Feb 16,2025
Dec 22 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Charged with transforming colossal state-owned enterprises into modern and competitiv...
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 28 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Unhabitual, perhaps too many, Samuel Gebreyohannes, 38, used to occasionally enjoy a couple of beers at breakfast. However, he recently swit...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transporting commodities, and f...
Feb 16 , 2025
Madame Kristalina Georgieva, managing director of the International Monetary Fund (IM...
Feb 9 , 2025
This week, the African Union's (AU) annual summit in Addis Abeba is set to be more th...
Feb 1 , 2025
Urban renewal is seldom gentle to those on the receiving end of redevelopment. Take s...
Jan 25 , 2025
Grand ambitions have long driven Ethiopia's successive leaders, but they remain weigh...
Feb 16 , 2025 . By YITBAREK GETACHEW
Ayat Mall, located near the roundabout popularly bearing its name, is at the centre o...
Feb 16 , 2025 . By BEZAWIT HULUAGER
Parliament has ratified a new proclamation imposing tough environmental regulations,...
Feb 16 , 2025 . By AKSAH ITALO
Dangote Group, the largest cement manufacturer in Africa, is making a 400-million-dol...
Feb 16 , 2025 . By AKSAH ITALO
Domestic steelmakers have been confronted with a severe crisis driven by escalating s...