Radar | Sep 21,2019
February 27 , 2021
By Christian Tesfaye ( Christian Tesfaye (email@example.com) is a researcher and Fortune'sOp-Ed Editor whose interests run amok in the directions of both print and audiovisual storytelling. )
For the uninitiated, income and wealth could mean the same thing. The former is a flow of money; the latter are assets held by a person or a household over a certain time. For many around the world, savings could be considered wealth. In Ethiopia, not so much.
This is because the Birr is not something we can count on to accurately represent our level of wealth. For instance, last year, annual general inflation stood around 20pc. Most commercial banks have a deposit interest of eight percent. This means that a household or a person with 100,000 Br in savings just lost 12,000 Br of their wealth. Since there is usually a double-digit inflationary rate – at around 16pc on average over the past year – the Birr is essentially an unreliable asset to hold as wealth.
Matters are not getting any better, which is concerning to low-income households. Over the past three years, nearly everything has been spiking in price, including food items. It is getting harder to put food on the table, let alone dealing with sudden health emergencies or covering rent.
Usually, behind such pressures is the unabated growth in the supply of money by a government that attempted to stimulate the economy through infrastructure projects. Here, a lot of money printing was done to cover budget deficits.
This time around, it is also the government’s doing but in a more direct way that could help the health of Ethiopia’s economy.
One of these reasons is the depreciation of the Birr. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) applauds this move. It believes that the current value of the Birr does not reflect its actual demand. The country should move toward a market-clearing rate to reflect the Birr's real value, which the Fund believes that it still has yet to do, and address one of the structural imbalances in the economy.
But Ethiopia subsists with the help of a large import bill. Basic stuff like wheat and edible oil are imported as are raw materials for the construction and manufacturing sectors. This means that the more expensive major currencies get – as valued in Birr – the cost of living rockets higher. Previous administrations have also taken this pill, but perhaps not as aggressively. Over the past fiscal year, the value of the Birr has fallen by about a third of what it was.
Another critical factor feeding inflation is the gradual lifting of subsidies on several essential goods and services. Most recently, this was fuel, which is subsidised for several billions of Birr every year. Currently, a litre of gasoline costs 25.82 Br, compared to an equivalent of 43 Br in Kenya, 40 Br in Rwanda and 43 Br in Uganda, according to GlobalPetrolPrices.com. The government is also gradually lifting prices on electricity where, here too, the country has one of the lowest in the world. The same kilowatt per hour of electricity in Ethiopia cost about 23 times less than in neighbouring Kenya last June.
Much of these subsidies help urban households more than they do rural ones. Both car benzene and electricity consumption are highest among urban households, thus, these are not even particularly pro-poor subsidies, at least not in a direct way. This is especially the case for sugar, which is no longer being subsidised as well.
Much of this seems in line with the recommendations the IMF has been hammering for as long as it has been engaged with Ethiopia. They are not terrible pieces of advice, especially if there is budget discipline. There is some reason to be optimistic about this as well.
“The government has maintained considerable budgetary discipline, with moderate increases in the general government budget deficit, to 2.8pc of GDP and government debt to GDP, while total SOE debt to GDP has fallen,” Fitch, the credit rating agency, has reported.
No less encouraging is the introduction of a T-bill market to move away from central bank financing, which since demand for money is artificial fuels inflation.
There are two major problems though. One is the political crisis, with an armed conflict that erupted in November 2020. This is not necessarily the sort of climate that is conducive to a dynamic private sector. Policies meant to help this very sector will be undermined if the government cannot mitigate the prevalence of political violence.
Also pertinent is the matter of consent. Most economists – at least those who agree there is a science to capitalism – would commend the government’s policy prescriptions. I do as well, mainly if there is a commitment to budget discipline.
The question is: does the Ethiopian public?
Addressing the economy’s imbalances requires breaking some eggs to make an omelette. The eggs, in this case, are low-income households, especially in urban areas. These people will bear the harshest economic conditions, even if the logic behind current policies is that they would be fundamental to creating a more resilient and dynamic economy in the future.
For this, the government needs to come clean on the economic direction it is taking the country. It needs to get public buy-in, no matter how disciplined it may be in its spending and borrowing. Low-income households will pay the biggest sacrifice, and whatever its merits, it is as much a political discussion as it is an economic one.
PUBLISHED ON Feb 27,2021 [ VOL 21 , NO 1087]
Radar | Sep 21,2019
Radar | Dec 29,2018
Agenda | Apr 10,2021
Commentaries | Apr 26,2019
Editorial | Feb 16,2019
International Stories | Apr 07,2020
Viewpoints | Jun 27,2020
Commentaries | Jan 26,2019
Commentaries | Feb 09,2019
Fortune News | Jan 02,2021
Fortune News | 36959 Views | Jul 18,2020
Fortune News | 16420 Views | Oct 12,2019
Fortune News | 15210 Views | Mar 19,2020
Exclusive Interviews | 15199 Views | Aug 10,2019
March 27 , 2021 . By BAMLAK FIKADU
An application developer who has recently taken up hiking to get some exercise, Migno...
February 13 , 2021 . By TADESSE TSEGAYE
In Arada, I stopped over by a hotel in front of Cinema Empire. I sat alone inside wit...
January 30 , 2021 . By FASIKA TADESSE
The Council of Ministers approved a regulation that will establish the Liability &...
January 16 , 2021
It was a sunny day on September 12, 1974. A machine gun mounted on top of a tank was...
Economic and political development go hand in hand with a good educational system. Th...
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country’s most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or tw...
April 10 , 2021
It is not often the case for regional states' leaders to swallow their vanity and dec...
April 3 , 2021
As an Auditor General, he was not the most conspicous of officials in the mainstream...
March 27 , 2021
In an unprecedented turn of irony, just as Ethiopia began an attempt to open up to th...
March 20 , 2021
There is never a dull moment in the tense and combative relationship between regulato...
PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD) at a Gala Dinner Called for the Awarding of the Félix Houphouët-Boigny Peace Prize
May 6 , 2019
Do not judge a book by its cover, we say. But we still judge all the same. It is much worse when it comes to a living, breathing person. We...
April 10 , 2021
Jemal Ahmed (left), CEO of MIDROC Investment Group, hands Adanech Abiebie (centre), deputy mayor of Addis Abeba, the city that is home to a...
April 10 , 2021 . By NEJAT AHMED
Ethiopia is spending 27.2 billion Br (over 660 million dollars in the current exchange rate) on importing...
Companies operating in the country's industrial parks have raised concerns with the central bank's recent...
April 10 , 2021 . By NEJAT AHMED
Half-a-dozen private higher learning institutions have been subject to regulatory action from the federal...
Or see contact page