Radar | Feb 29,2020
Apr 22 , 2022
By Christian Tesfaye
Once again, we hear murmurs of opening up the financial sector to foreign players. The discussion gained traction in the aftermath of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed’s (PhD) statement during the inauguration of the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia’s (CBE) headquarters a couple of months ago.
Historically, two main arguments have been forwarded against opening the financial sector to the global economy. The first, often touted, is that the country does not have the regulatory capacity to provide proper oversight of foreign banks and the financial instruments they may provide.
There are problems with this view. It confuses liberalisation with deregulation. Both indeed refer to the removal of state restrictions on business but of a very different kind. The former is a relaxation of state controls over capital and trade. In the case of the financial sector, it is the type of reduction in state control that would allow for the entry of non-domestic financial institutions.
But none of this entails that, once allowed entry, the institutions would be able to introduce any financial instrument of their choosing. When they operate in Ethiopia, they have to play under the country's regulatory environment. Under the current laws, they mostly only can engage in savings and loan services. If they wish to introduce more complex financial instruments that do not yet exist in the country, they have to get the green light from the central bank.
People should rest assured that opening the financial sector will not amount to the introduction of complex products such as derivatives, which were responsible for the 2008 global financial crisis. Significant levels of deregulation need to be taken for Ethiopia’s laughably traditional financial sector to be transformed so radically. If nothing else, this is merely self-flattery because the financial and economic ecosystem is not even nearly developed enough to support a market for such products. If we are talking merely about liberalisation, foreign banks only get to operate services that the central bank already regulates.
Of course, the regulatory environment has to change to accommodate, incentivise and encourage the entry of foreign banks. But this only brings us to the second reason why the conclusion that the Ethiopian authorities lack regulatory capacity is misleading. Frankly speaking, it is not that big a leap compared to the updating of the regulatory regime in the telecom sector. It is underselling the sophistication of Ethiopia's business and finance community to a ludicrous degree.
I do not say this merely by looking at the situation at home. Here is a good example. Standard Bank, the South African giant, which is also the largest bank in Africa, has expanded its services into Malawi, Mozambique, Tanzania, Uganda and Zimbabwe.
If these countries are confident enough in their regulatory capacity to open up, should we not? We may believe that the likes of Kenya, Nigeria, South Africa and Egypt are ahead of us when it comes to finance, but we cannot even do as well as Zimbabwe and Uganda, which are supposed to be at a similar level of economic development? Let us not sell ourselves so short.
The other arguments against liberalisation are profit expatriation and hot money. Let us deal with the latter first. Hot money is a phenomenon of lack of capital controls, where money enters and exists a country very fluidly. It is not the same as liberalising the financial sector. A simple way to conceptualise this would be to keep in mind is that the entry of foreign banks is largely just FDI, most likely brownfield investments. The only money they can take out is profits, or what counts in the books as owner’s equity if they decide to sell, as long as capital controls remain in place. Here too, rest assured.
But would they not expatriate large amounts of profits in foreign currency?
Sure. But is that not what we want, for investors to get a good return on their investment in Ethiopia so they can keep coming? Again, I will raise the issue of the telecom sector with the recent entry of Safaricom Ethiopia. The hundreds of millions of dollars they paid in license fees and the billions of dollars they have promised to invest over the years are not charity. Or take the brewery industry, where multinational corporations are the major players. It is a two-way relationship. They want to make money over the long-term, just as any bank that would like to enter Ethiopia’s market will be looking to do. It is up to our policymakers and authorities to ensure that jobs are created, the financial sector modernised and that gains to the economy are realised in a mutually beneficial manner.
By all means, let the sector loose.
PUBLISHED ON
Apr 22,2022 [ VOL
23 , NO
1147]
Radar | Feb 29,2020
Sunday with Eden | Aug 08,2020
Radar | May 21,2022
Editorial | Nov 27,2021
Fortune News | Jun 05,2021
Commentaries | Nov 04,2023
Radar | Jun 04,2022
Featured | Aug 10,2019
My Opinion | Sep 17,2022
Featured | Sep 28,2019
Photo Gallery | 96763 Views | May 06,2019
Photo Gallery | 88946 Views | Apr 26,2019
My Opinion | 67177 Views | Aug 14,2021
Commentaries | 65764 Views | Oct 02,2021
Feb 24 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
Abel Yeshitila, a real estate developer with a 12-year track record, finds himself unable to sell homes in his latest venture. Despite slash...
Feb 10 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
In his last week's address to Parliament, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) painted a picture of an economy...
Jan 7 , 2024
In the realm of international finance and diplomacy, few cities hold the distinction that Addis Abeba doe...
Sep 30 , 2023 . By AKSAH ITALO
On a chilly morning outside Ke'Geberew Market, Yeshi Chane, a 35-year-old mother cradling her seven-month-old baby, stands amidst the throng...
Apr 20 , 2024
In a departure from its traditionally opaque practices, the National Bank of Ethiopia...
Apr 13 , 2024
In the hushed corridors of the legislative house on Lorenzo Te'azaz Road (Arat Kilo)...
Apr 6 , 2024
In a rather unsettling turn of events, the state-owned Commercial Bank of Ethiopia (C...
Mar 30 , 2024
Ethiopian authorities find themselves at a crossroads in the shadow of a global econo...
Apr 20 , 2024
Ethiopia's economic reform negotiations with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) are in their fourth round, taking place in Washington, D...
Apr 20 , 2024 . By BERSABEH GEBRE
An undercurrent of controversy surrounds the appointment of founding members of Amhara Bank after regulat...
An ambitious cooperative housing initiative designed to provide thousands with affordable homes is mired...
Apr 20 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Ethiopia's juice manufacturers confront formidable economic challenges following the reclassification of...