Radar | Mar 20,2021
Jan 15 , 2022
By Koichi Hamada
The rigid stances of Modern Monetary Theoryâs devotees and detractors have not lent themselves to productive discussion. This is a serious loss for policymakers, because MMT includes both problematic propositions and perfectly reasonable â even highly useful â ones, writes Koichi Hamada, professor emeritus at Yale University and former special adviser to former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe.
When Democratic Senator Joe Manchin announced that he would not support US President Joe Bidenâs Build Back Better Act â effectively dooming the presidentâs signature legislative initiative â he cited Americaâs âstaggering debt.â His concerns echoed those of Bidenâs Republican opponents, who insist that all that spending would expand the deficit and leave future generations groaning under the weight of a heavy tax burden.
But would it?
Proponents of Modern Monetary Theory would beg to differ.
The Build Back Better Actâs detractors subscribe to the conventional Ricardian assumption that, over time, a government must balance its budget, just like a private firm. But MMT holds that, as long as debt is denominated in a countryâs own currency, its government cannot default. Excessive government spending can fuel inflation, but as long as prices are stable, governments can spend away, using fiscal deficits â rather than tax revenues â to support employment and finance public goods.
While MMT is not new, it has been gaining traction in recent years. And a significant share of its following nowadays comes across almost as zealots, unwilling to brook any dissent. Meanwhile, mainstream economists largely regard MMT as tantamount to professional heresy, with some avoiding so much as uttering its name.
Needless to say, the rigid stances of MMTâs devotees and detractors have not lent themselves to productive discussion. This is a serious loss for policymakers because MMT includes both problematic propositions and perfectly reasonable â even highly useful â positions.
In the latter category, the idea that stands out is essentially functional finance theory. Proposed by Abba Lerner in 1943, FFT holds that, because governments borrowing in their own currency can always print money to service their debts, but still face inflation risks, they should aim to balance supply and demand at full employment, rather than fret about balancing the budget. In Lernerâs view, well-targeted deficit spending is an effective way for governments to âmaintain prosperity.â
FFT supports the case for Build Back Better, which includes spending on goods like education, infrastructure, and the green transition. The Biden administration claims that the act would be financed entirely with tax revenues.
But even if that turned out not to be the case, as his detractors predict, would not inadequate infrastructure, depleted human capital, and a planet ravaged by climate change hurt future generations more?
To be sure, US policymakers broadly recognise the importance of such investments, especially in infrastructure; the US Congress recently passed, with bipartisan support, a one trillion dollar spending plan that aims to advance objectives like overhauling the electricity grid, upgrading railways, and expanding access to high-speed internet. But even some Democrats demanded that the new funds contained in the package be entirely offset by new tax revenue â a development that highlights enduring resistance to the logic of MMT (or FFT).
And yet, as the Wall Street Journalâs James Mackintosh recently argued, this may be largely a ârhetoricalâ issue. After all, he notes, âthe infrastructure act is, in fact, debt-financed anyway.â And it may well be that many of Build Back Betterâs supporters are not convinced by Bidenâs claims that tax revenues will offset the new spending, but are not that concerned about it.
But MMT and FFT are not synonymous. MMT includes two additional propositions that, in my view, are unsound. The first is that monetary policy should be conducted in such a way that it facilitates fiscal-policy decisions, such as by maintaining a constant (very low) interest rate.
This expresses a crucial feature of post-Keynesian economics: interest rates, rather than money supply, are the key variables. This defies conventional economic thinking, which focuses on the interaction of stock and flow variables and the role of expectations. More important, if interest rates are held constant, and prices start to rise, inflation could snowball. MMT proponents would advocate tax hikes as a way to manage aggregate demand and control inflation. But, given what we know about asset dynamics, this would be a hard sell.
MMTâs second problematic proposition â that governments should provide a job guarantee in order to maintain full employment while mitigating inflationary pressures â is even harder to defend. It simply moves too far in the direction of socialist labour allocation, and enables governments to wield excessive control over workersâ wages.
When I explained MMT to former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, he compared it to preparing fugu. If done correctly, the pufferfish is a sublime delicacy. But if the chef makes even a minor mistake, the diner could suffer a rapid and painful death.
It is an apt metaphor. If policymakers adopt the positive elements of MMT â essentially, FFT â they will gain new options for bolstering prosperity for current and future generations. But one wrong cut, and the results could be fatal.
PUBLISHED ON Jan 15,2022 [ VOL 22 , NO 1133]
Radar | Mar 20,2021
Fortune News | Jan 05,2020
My Opinion | Apr 09,2023
Fortune News | Jul 08,2019
Fortune News | Jan 19,2019
Fortune News | Sep 23,2023
Editorial | Nov 30,2019
Radar | Jan 11,2020
Fortune News | May 18,2019
Fortune News | Apr 26,2019
Photo Gallery | 91578 Views | May 06,2019
Photo Gallery | 83851 Views | Apr 26,2019
Commentaries | 65389 Views | Oct 02,2021
My Opinion | 65343 Views | Aug 14,2021
Commentaries | Feb 24,2024
Life Matters | Feb 24,2024
My Opinion | Feb 24,2024
Sunday with Eden | Feb 24,2024
Agenda | Feb 24,2024
Editorial | Feb 24,2024
Feb 24 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
Abel Yeshitila, a real estate developer with a 12-year track record, finds himself unable to sell homes in his latest venture. Despite slash...
Feb 10 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
In his last week's address to Parliament, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) painted a picture of an economy...
Jan 7 , 2024
In the realm of international finance and diplomacy, few cities hold the distinction that Addis Abeba doe...
Sep 30 , 2023 . By AKSAH ITALO
On a chilly morning outside Ke'Geberew Market, Yeshi Chane, a 35-year-old mother cradling her seven-month-old baby, stands amidst the throng...
Every country is eager to attract foreign direct investment (FDI) â and for good re...
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country's most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or two...
Feb 24 , 2024
The recent policy pronouncement by the Transport Minister, Alemu Sime (PhD), of a pla...
Feb 17 , 2024
In the vast auditoriums of Addis Abeba, far from the era when flamboyant figures like...
Feb 10 , 2024
In a last week session before Parliament, Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) was seen ad...
In a world increasingly attuned to the nuances of data reliability and its implicatio...
During a work deployment abroad five years ago, I encountered a woman whose frailty w...
I am greeted by the sight of numerous women lining the streets upon returning home from work each day. Their offerings range from fresh prod...
Feb 24 , 2024
The once-booming real estate market faces a downturn, with developers struggling with declining demand and falling prices. Developers see de...
Feb 24 , 2024 . By BERSABEH GEBRE
A crisis looms over the fertile lands of Gambella and Benishangul Gumuz regional states, where the future of commercial farming was once in...
Feb 24 , 2024 . By BERSABEH GEBRE
A major initiative by the Addis Abeba City Administration targeting food inflation and improving accessib...
Feb 24 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
A concerning picture of public health safety was painted by the Ethiopian Food & Drug Authority (EFDA...