Life Matters | Aug 07,2021
The Black Lives Matter movement has been useful in shining light on profiling, racism and systematic victimisation of African Americans in the United States. The movement is indispensable to having started a conversation.
But like many movements, it is not without flaws. Some statistics are barely mentioned, especially by international media quick to report the shooting of an unarmed African teenager.
Indeed, American police officers shoot and kill far more people than their counterparts in Western Europe. But it is also notable that Americans own a lot of guns and police officers are far more likely to be killed in the United States than, say, Finland or France.
Let us also remember that gang violence takes many more black lives than police officers do - which thus should also have gained as much attention in the movement - and that African-American cops are just as likely as their Caucasian counterparts to gun down black suspects.
The Hate U Give touches upon the movement. It is about a high school student, Starr (Amandla Stenberg), from a relatively well-off family in a predominantly black neighbourhood. Her parents send her and her brother to an upscale school out of town, where everyone is “college-bound”.
She leads two lives. In her neighbourhood, she tries not to seem too influenced by her rich white friends and boyfriend, while in school she tries not to seem too ghetto. But her life is upended one night when, after a party in her neighbourhood while taking a ride with a childhood friend, they are stopped by a police officer. There is an argument, her friend is told to step out of the car and keep his hands where they can be visible.
But the friend casually reaches inside the car to get a comb and is shot dead by the officer that assumed he was holding a gun.
Starr is the only witness to the shooting. At first, her instinct is to keep quiet, mostly to protect herself against victimisation. Most worrying is that her friend used to deal drugs for one of the most notorious gangs in the neighbourhood, and testifying may shine a light on an issue that some powerful people would prefer to stay in the dark.
The moral question becomes, should she quietly walk away, go to college, get a good job and stay as far away from her neighbourhood and its influences as possible? Or should she fight, as she says, for her people to get justice?
It would have been preferable had the movie been about the moral and ideological debate over the shooting of unarmed African-Americans by police officers. The film tries to explore this complicated matter but concludes too soon that any argument that does not support the Black Lives Matter movement is racist. It also concerns itself more with Starr, her determination to speak up and the importance of looking after “my people.”
The film is very well directed and acted. The contrast between Starr’s life in a predominantly black neighbourhood and inside that of a school with mostly rich white kids is impressive and revealing. The film does indulge itself in sentimentality - sometimes it is over the top - but given the sensitivity of the issue, it can be tolerated.
But it would have been more constructive had the film elected to start the conversation only and not end it. It would have been appreciated had it been courageous enough to allow audiences to make up their minds about Black Lives Matter instead of bullying the audience into agreeing with its worldview and suggesting that everyone that does not agree with the movement must be a racist.
Indeed, there are those that disagree with it simply because they are racist. But I am also sceptical about movements that prosecute those that disagree with them. Biases are inherent to any being, even non-humans, since we all perceive the world through our eyes. A difference of opinions thus should always be tolerated, not because it will always exist, but because they help us understand ourselves and the world better.
Fortunately, we can choose to rise above these biases. Unfortunately, when decisions need to be made in split seconds, the subconscious kicks in and complicates matters. Thus, that police officer - who saw a black suspect in the middle of the night in a black neighbourhood pull something out of his car - was informed in his decision making by the rate of deaths of police officers in that neighbourhood. He would most likely lack the sober mind to extend the benefit of the doubt to the suspect in those fractions of a second.
There have been many studies that show that it matters little whether or not the officer himself is white or African-American.
This is a far more complicated moral and philosophical debate than what the movie assumes to be just a case of an evil white cop killing a poor black kid. It is instead a matter of the systematic disenfranchisement of African-Americans. Unfortunately, that would have taken far more courage and sophistication to address, and the film is the worse off for not delving deeper than the usual mainstream debate.
PUBLISHED ON Dec 05,2018 [ VOL 19 , NO 971]
Life Matters | Aug 07,2021
Viewpoints | Dec 04,2020
Viewpoints | Dec 25,2021
Viewpoints | Nov 02,2019
Commentaries | Aug 29,2020
My Opinion | Nov 14,2020
My Opinion | Mar 27,2021
Viewpoints | Mar 09,2019
Fortune News | Dec 29,2018
View From Arada | Jan 03,2021
Photo Gallery | 54704 Views | May 06,2019
Fortune News | 47175 Views | Jul 18,2020
Photo Gallery | 46531 Views | Apr 26,2019
Fortune News | 46184 Views | Sep 01,2021
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country’s most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or tw...
August 14 , 2022
The call for lofty ideals such as national dialogue and consensus has been as old as...
August 6 , 2022
Few initiatives by the administration of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) have been pu...
July 30 , 2022
Ethiopia’s banking industry is not merely underdeveloped. It has historically regre...
July 23 , 2022
The flip side of a government spending plan is financing. Behind the campaign promise...
PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD) at a Gala Dinner Called for the Awarding of the Félix Houphouët-Boigny Peace Prize
May 6 , 2019
Having studied psychology, I am fascinated by how our thoughts shape our lives. I am also interested in mental health and try my best to cre...
August 14 , 2022 . By RAHEL BOGALE
Federal authorities approved submissions by the Addis Abeba University (AAU) administ...
August 13 , 2022 . By BERSABEH GEBRE
The federal government is imposing a new tax, hoping to generate an additional 22 bil...
August 15 , 2022
Agricultural authorities have backpedalled on a decision to raise the minimum price t...
August 13 , 2022 . By ELSHADAY HAGOS
Transport authorities have introduced unique license plates to vehicles owned by indi...
Or see contact page