
Jun 26 , 2021
By Yehualashet Tamiru Tegegn , Dagmawit Kifle
The amended Commercial Code characteristically contains some of the traditional protections to minority owners in share companies. Unfortunately, it is silent on modern safeguards, such as those protecting against 'freeze-outs,' write Yehualashet Tamiru Tegegn (yehuala5779@gmail.com), adjunct lecturer at Addis Abeba University and an associate at MTA, and Dagmawit Kifle, an independent lawyer.
Majority rule is the cardinal principle of business law, whereby most shareholders take the decision-making power in a company. Why should business organisations operate with the principle of majority shareholders rule?
There are two theories. One is a hangover from political democracy, where any shareholder should only have one vote a share and everyone needs to have a say in the management of a company. In economics, majority rule is justified for the company's effective operation, where rules and regulations are put together to ensure that the view of the majority of owners of a firm is respected.
Minority shareholders are those that own less than half of the total share outstanding and thus cannot control the corporation’s management or singlehandedly elect directors. The critical element here is effective control, the meaning of which is country-specific. But there are some yardsticks we can use to identify it: if a shareholder owns more than a certain level of voting shares issued; at least half of the directors are appointed by the shareholder and if a shareholder, either through related parties or directly, has a dominating control over corporate strategy outcomes.
There are instances in which the interest of minority and majority shareholders can conflict. In such cases, the latter may attempt to manipulate the company structure for their benefit at the expense of the former. As a result, minority shareholders are vulnerable to exploitation in the absence of adequate legal protection. This exploitation may take various forms: asset misuse, transfer pricing, profit allocation and acquisition of other business organisation that majority shareholders own. The law needs to protect minority shareholders.
One of the primary protections for such shareholders is the right to call up a general meeting, which plays an important role in the company's direction. It is also one of the most substantive legal protections afforded to minority shareholders under Ethiopian law. Once requested, the auditor is obliged to call a general meeting with shareholders representing at least a fifth of the capital of the company.
Going together with this protection is the right to appoint an independent auditor. Under Ethiopia’s revised Commercial Code, every share company must have at least one independent and impartial external and assistant auditor. A shareholder representing no less than a fifth of the capital of the company can appoint such a person.
Another protection is the right to challenge a resolution. Like many other legal systems, resolutions adopted at general meetings by the vote of the majority shall be binding. Any shareholder whose interest is affected by the resolution can apply to the court to invalidate such resolutions within three months.
Minority shareholders also have the right to access information from the management, which is necessary to take a position on agendas tabled during general meetings. However, access to information by the board may be prohibited where it is deemed that disclosure would cause significant damage to the company. A shareholder denied this right might sue, at which point the court will decide whether there is sufficient justification to hold back the information.
A minority shareholder also has the right to seek the dissolution of the company. A company may be dissolved by order of the court based on the application of just a single shareholder. A good cause should be determined on a case-by-case basis, but it could constitute a scenario where the company has failed at its main establishment objective.
Despite these and other protections accorded to the minority shareholders, the Commercial Code has failed to incorporate some of the modern safeguards for minority shareholders.
One is lack of protection against ‘freeze-out,’ using the corporate control vested in a majority of shareholders or board of directors to eliminate minority shareholders from the enterprise. It could also be an action that reduces the relative significance of their voting power, claims on corporate assets, or deprives them of corporate income or advantages. A freeze-out may take place through a merger or consolidation and may be utilised by the majority to transform the original company into a new one in which the rights of minorities are diminished.
This extends to the election of board directors, which are elected by a general meeting. Even if minority shareholders manage to get one representative or two in there, the majority can still freeze them out at any given time as directors are subject to general meeting decisions. They may be removed even without good cause and in the presence of a contrary stipulation under the memorandum of association. This will have a determinate effect on the minority shareholders since majority shareholders will use it to circumvent their representation on the board.
On top of these gaps, the absence of email voting system, proportional voting system, lack of veto right on some selected issues and lack of constructive derivative actions are some of the missing legal protections for minority shareholders under the revised Commercial Code.
PUBLISHED ON
Jun 26,2021 [ VOL
22 , NO
1104]
Fortune News | Sep 09,2023
Radar | Jul 11,2021
Editorial | Feb 22,2020
Fortune News | Jun 19,2021
Commentaries | Jul 20,2024
View From Arada | Sep 06,2020
Fortune News | Feb 15,2020
Fortune News | Apr 30,2021
Featured | Apr 20,2019
Commentaries | Jan 26,2019
My Opinion | 126788 Views | Aug 14,2021
My Opinion | 122911 Views | Aug 21,2021
My Opinion | 121070 Views | Sep 10,2021
My Opinion | 118967 Views | Aug 07,2021
Dec 22 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Charged with transforming colossal state-owned enterprises into modern and competitiv...
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 28 , 2024 . By TIZITA SHEWAFERAW
Unhabitual, perhaps too many, Samuel Gebreyohannes, 38, used to occasionally enjoy a couple of beers at breakfast. However, he recently swit...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transporting commodities, and f...
Mar 30 , 2025
When the private satellite channel, Ethiopian Broadcasting Service (EBS), aired an em...
Mar 23 , 2025
Getachew Redda, head of the Tigray Interim Regional Administration (TIRA), at least u...
Mar 16 , 2025
Ask anyone about the population of Addis Abeba, and a straightforward answer proves e...
Mar 9 , 2025
Five years ago, 11 non-governmental organisations (NGOs), together with 40 allies acr...
Mar 30 , 2025
The brewing industry faces a storm, with barley shortages leading to a substantial sp...
Mar 30 , 2025 . By BEZAWIT HULUAGER
Federal officials are accelerating the shift towards domestically assembled electric...
Mar 30 , 2025 . By AKSAH ITALO
The federal government is pushing towards a single account for the treasury to consol...
The Ministry of Transport & Logistics faced scrutiny after federal auditors uncov...