Editorial | Jul 13,2020
Members of parliament have voted in favour of a record-high supplementary budget bill Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed's (PhD) administration motioned last month. The bill met objections from nine of the 309 parliamentarians in attendance last week, while seven abstained.
The supplementary budget - 122 billion Br - represents a fifth of the 561 billion Br federal budget Parliament approved for 2021/22. It comes when the budget deficit is projected to reach four percent of the GDP, and as year-on-year headline inflation reached 35pc last December. How the administration plans to finance the supplementary budget exacerbates worries that it will fuel the inflationary pressure in the economy.
Much of the additional budget (90 billion Br) is earmarked for the Ethiopian National Defense Forces (ENDF), which has been in a militarized conflict for over a year in the north and flared up insurgency in the south-western parts of the country. The military receives four-fold the initial budget Parliament approved in July 2021. The military, along with the justice and security sectors, has consumed a third of the 49 billion Br allotted for the recurrent expenditures in the first five months of the fiscal year, reveals a report by the Ministry of Finance.
Emergency food assistance and market stabilisation procurement for wheat accounts for eight billion Birr of the supplementary budget, while an equivalent amount is earmarked for contingency. Of the balance, five billion Birr will be spent on reconstructing infrastructure damaged by the civil war, and two billion Birr will go to the rehabilitation of irrigation dams at state-owned sugar estates.
These include the Omo-Kuraz, Tana Beles, Tendaho and Kesem estates, all run by the Ethiopian Sugar Corporation (ESC). Initially planned for sugarcane, the Ministry of Irrigation & Lowlands wants to use them for wheat production, according to Birhanu Megersa (PhD), a state minister for Irrigation & Lowlands.
"The full potential is not utilised by sugarcane plantation," he said.
The motion tabled before Parliament by the Ministry of Finance attributed the supplementary funds to budget restructuring and insufficient domestic revenues collection to cover public expenditures. The federal government targets to collect 368 billion Br this year. Over the first five months of this fiscal year, the Ministry of Revenues collected 147 billion Br, 16pc higher than last year and close to 90pc of its initial target. Though the figure has grown numerically, it has stagnated or even fallen when factored to inflation.
Eyob Tekalign (PhD), a state minister for Finance, told Parliament last week COVID-19 has had detrimental effects on revenues collection.
However, funding from external sources has also been sluggish. In the first quarter, the federal government received 137 million dollars in external loans, 32pc lower than the same period last year. According to individuals familiar with the external debt process, the government hopes to source a 300 million dollars loan from the World Bank and 150 million dollars from other sources.
Fundraising domestically and in the Diaspora is one avenue officials aspire to mobilise additional financing. The ministries of Education and Health have been granted nods to kick start campaigns. The Ministry of Education has already raised 42 million dollars, which its officials say will be used to rebuild 40 schools in the north damaged by war.
Disaster financing has been an issue officials of the Finance Ministry have mulled over in the macroeconomic framework. Although using available contingency funds is included in the budget, the administration has already spent the 11.3 billion Br in contingency budget.
Reallocating funds from other budget items to respond to rehabilitation and reconstruction needs is considered. According to State Minister Eyob, the administration has reassigned about 25 billion Br through a project restructuring regime this year though he declined from disclosing which projects have been restructured. Five billion Birr has been saved for recurrent expenses as well, he disclosed.
Governments often finance budget deficits through raising taxes, cutting back on public expenditures or borrowing from domestic sources. In contrast to the past few years, the administration has opted for domestic borrowing to finance the supplementary budget Parliament approved last week fully.
Eyob says the resources to finance the supplementary budget will be raised from financial institutions through the sale of treasury bills (T-bills).
Financing the budget deficit using treasury bills is not a bad option, says Patrick Heinisch, an economist and capital markets researcher.
“That is what has been done for a long time in Europe and the US without exerting burdensome inflationary pressure,” he said.
However, Heinisch observed much more demand for Euro and Dollar-denominated debt as these currencies are global reserve currencies.
“Demand for Birr-denominated debt is much more limited," he said. "When it comes to T-bill financing in Ethiopia, my primary concern is not inflationary pressure but the stability of the financial system."
His worries arise from the low yield rate of T-bills, which is far below the inflation rate.
"T-bill financing is better than borrowing directly from the central bank," he said.
Officials maintain the administration is determined to avoid direct advances from the central bank, but the figures show otherwise.
Direct advances from the central bank grew by 52 billion Br at the end of last year and topped 113 billion Br (30 billion Br increase) in the first quarter of the current fiscal year. It is a phenomenal turnaround compared to 2019/20, where direct borrowing from the central bank dropped to 31 billion Br from 123 billion Br the previous year.
Heinisch urges officials to seek foreign assistance to pay for reconstruction and rehabilitation works in war-ravaged areas of the north.
"I would advise the government to reach out to donors and the Diaspora as the domestic financial market is rather small," Heinisch told Fortune. "Donors and the Diaspora can provide funding in foreign exchange, which helps stabilise the exchange rate and causes less inflation."
The analyst contends that it is crucial to finalise debt restructuring under the common framework agreement with the IMF. According to data from the World Bank, interest and principal payments on the external debt of 2.2 billion dollars are due in 2022, a few hundred million dollars short of the entire supplementary budget. However, no update has been provided on the negotiations with creditors since September 2021, when the creditor committee met first.
"The government needs to make more effort to achieve results," Heinisch said.
Three weeks before the last fiscal year ended, Parliament had approved a 38.4 billion Br supplementary budget, financed mainly from domestic sources. Of the total, about 11 billion was meant to be covered by external sources. Subsequently, the National Bank of Ethiopia (NBE) held two auctions before the end of the year, raising 47.7 billion Br. Uncharacteristically, the central bank continued to hold auctions every week until the end of July, unlike its tradition of bi-monthly auction.
Alisa Strobel, a senior economist for Sub-Saharan Africa at IHS Markit, argues that additional budget spending was inevitable.
“However, higher reconstruction finances suggest that we are likely to see a higher fiscal deficit in 2022," said the economist.
According to Cepheus Growth Capital Partners (Cepheus), a private investment firm, the budget deficit is expected to shoot up to four percent of the GDP from 2.7pc a year before.
PUBLISHED ON [ VOL , NO ]
Editorial | Jul 13,2020
Editorial | May 28,2022
Fortune News | Jun 09,2019
Viewpoints | Sep 18,2021
Fortune News | Oct 09,2021
Agenda | Jun 12,2021
Fortune News | Jun 04,2022
Radar | Jun 05,2021
Commentaries | Jul 24,2021
Viewpoints | May 11,2019
July 2 , 2022 . By RUTH TAYE
On a rainy afternoon last week, a coffee processing facility in the capital's Akaki-Qality District was abuzz with activ...
November 27 , 2021
Against my will, I have witnessed the most terrible defeat of reason and the most sa...
November 13 , 2021
Plans and reality do not always gel. They rarely do in a fast-moving world. Every act...
October 16 , 2021 . By HAWI DADHI
Residing in a country with no capital market, an organised marketplace for trading se...
The pandemic, armed conflicts and natural disasters have again brought the importance...
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country’s most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or tw...
July 2 , 2022
After nearly two years since the civil war broke out in northern Ethiopia, adversarie...
June 25 , 2022
It is not the best of times to be in charge of governance in Ethiopia, whether at the...
June 18 , 2022
Some of Ethiopia's economic policymakers may take solace from realising that inflatio...
June 11 , 2022
The stereotype many people have of parliamentarians is as clueless seat fillers who exist to rubber stamp legislative bi...
PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD) at a Gala Dinner Called for the Awarding of the Félix Houphouët-Boigny Peace Prize
May 6 , 2019
A couple of years ago, I was having a conversation with a friend and mentor who has...
The advertising industry in Ethiopia has come a long way. They are not only getting better and more creat...
Or see contact page