BUSINESS & ECONOMY INDICATORS TRENDS FORTUNE+ VIDEO TENDERS JOBS SPONSORED CONTENTS FORTUNE AUDIO

COVID-19 UPDATES: All the stories and commentaries on Coronavirus, in one place

Country Club Developers (CCD).

The Council of Constitutional Inquiry, the constitutional interpretation advisory body, issued a stay-order on a previous judgment that ruled Country Club Developers (CCD) to deliver disputed houses to the buyers.

CCD filed a complaint with the Council stating the decision given by judges during the court battle with the buyers was in violation of Ethiopia’s constitution. The letter signed by Chief Justice Meaza Ashenafi, president of the 11-member court, on January 28, 2019, reads that until the case is reviewed, the decision passed by the Execution Court for the delivery of the houses to the buyers will be put on hold.

The lawyers of CCD presented the letter from the Council on February 14, 2018, at the Federal High Court Sixth Civil Bench. The judges, after reading the letter, put the previous decision on hold until the Council reviews the case.

The ruling by the Council states that the case should instead have been seen by the Oromia Regional State Supreme Court as the real estate is located in Legetafo. Although some of the litigating parties are non-nationals, which makes it a federal case, the Constitution delegates powers of the Federal High Court to the regional supreme courts, according to CCD’s appeal.



It was stated that the classification of power and jurisdiction of the different courts is laid out in the constitution, making the issue a matter of constitutional interpretation.

The case that led to this dispute began eight years ago when the six home buyers, some of the members of the American diaspora, sued the company calming that it had failed to deliver the homes within a contractually stipulated 18-month schedule.


They stated that the real estate developer terminated their agreements as they declined to sign an amended contract with new terms and conditions.

The home buyers had bought six homes in 2006 and the next year with a price range between 1.7 million Br and 3.1 million Br, in Legatafo, 11Km northeast of the capital from CCD.




The home buyers stated that they were asked to make an additional payment of half a million Birr due to inflationary rise in the cost of construction materials by the real estate company, which was founded in 2002 with a registered capital of 20 million Br.

All the other homebuyers, except the six, refused to make the increased payment and took the case to Federal High Court, during the trial of which CDC had raised its jurisdiction issues as a preliminary objection. But the court took jurisdiction over the cases stating that since it involves foreign nationals the matter should be heard in a federal court.

The court ruled in favour of the homebuyers, ordering the developer to transfer the houses to the buyers according to the terms and conditions of the initial contract. Opposing the ruling, CCD appealed to the Supreme Court, but the judgment of the lower court was sustained.

CCD then took the case to the Court of Cassation where the bench passed a decision that again favoured the home buyers by ordering CCD to deliver the houses to the homebuyers with no price adjustment.


The six homebuyers subsequently appealed to the Execution Court to enforce the judgment in July 2016, for which the developer requested an additional 16 months to finalise and deliver the homes. But, the Court gave the company a deadline of November 2017 to hand over the houses to the judgment creditors.

In January 2019, almost a year after the final deadline elapsed, the home buyers again appealed to the execution court stating that CCD did not deliver the house in the indicated time. They also claimed that the company had failed to finalise and equip the houses with kitchen taps, exhaust hoods, boilers, gates and water and electric utilities.

The court then summoned Mesele Haile (PhD), general manager of the company, who explained that the company was challenged to deliver the houses due to the forex crunch.

After the hearing, the court ordered CCD to equip and deliver the houses by February 14 and the case was adjourned to the February 14 date to ensure that the company had adhered to the ruling. The lawyers though showed up with the injunction from the Council, which means that the delivery decision will now be put on hold until it is reviewed.

If the Council finds that there is a constitutional issue, it will recommend a decision to the House of Federation, which will have the final say.


PUBLISHED ON Feb 16,2019 [ VOL 19 , NO 981]



Related Posts

Put your comments here


Editors' Pick

Editorial

How to Counter Rising, Unbridled Nationalism

January 16 , 2021

It was a sunny day on September 12, 1974. A machine gun mounted on top of a tank was...

Featured

CHRISTMAS TREES: A Tale of Two Markets

January 3 , 2021 . By ABDUREZAK LESMAN

Women wearing netela, a white cotton garment with woven coloured borders, and men in...

Agenda

Leather Industry Desperate to Save own Skin

December 26 , 2020 . By MAYA MISIKIR 

Black and white markings on their legs and large semi-circular rimmed horns that stre...

Exclusive Interviews

Rockstone's Dietrich Rogge Looks to Fit into Addis

December 12 , 2020

Dietrich Rogge, founder and CEO of Rockstone, a German-based real estate developer an...

Commentaries

Reconciliation: Underrated Element in the Transitional Justice Process of Ethiopia

Few are better authorities on the concept of reconciliation than Nelson Mandela. â...

It's Never Too Late to Restart Ethiopia's Politics, Economic Circumstances

Since Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) took office in April 2018, his administration h...

Fineline

Leaders of the National . . .

Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...

When the country’s most. . .

When the country’s most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or tw...

Editorial

How to Counter Rising, Unbridled Nationalism

January 16 , 2021

It was a sunny day on September 12, 1974. A machine gun mounted on top of a tank was...

Not to Undo Abiy Ahmed's Pledge for Credible National Elections

January 9 , 2021

There is something curious about elections that have been conducted in Ethiopia since...

To Millions Suffering, IGAD Continues to be a Disappointment

January 2 , 2021

One by one, Workneh Gebeyehu (PhD), executive secretary of the Intergovernmental Auth...

Economic Planning Needs to Learn the Cost of Indiscipline

December 26 , 2020

It is refreshing to see a publicised high-level government meeting become somewhat co...

Gallery

2020 in Posterity

January 5 , 2021

With an election initially expected to be held in 2020, the past year was supposed to be eventful. It did not disappoint. In fact, it outpaced expectations. Much of 2020 was talked about, analysed and debated. And thanks to technology, it was caught...

TIGRAY VOTES DESPITE "NULL & VOID" THREAT

September 9 , 2020

IN-PICTURE: LAUREATE'S RECEPTION  

December 14 , 2019

PM Abiy Ahmed (PhD) at a Gala Dinner Called for the Awarding of the Félix Houphouët-Boigny Peace Prize

May 6 , 2019

Faces, Voices of Addis Abeba

April 26 , 2019

Mourning Nation, Grieving World

March 17 , 2019

Sunday With Eden

From the US to Ethiopia, the Need for Accountability

We witnessed hitherto unthinkable violence erupting in Washington, DC at Capitol Hill...

What It Takes to Not Repeat 2020

The COVID-19 pandemic, having seen over 126,000 cases reported across Ethiopia and leading to the deaths of around 2,000 people, had a silve...

Life Matters

Country of Negative Nellys

I was a month postnatal when I discovered a familiar way of communicating in Ethiopia. Many visitors came to see me, as they often do after...

The Dangers of Nocturnal Taxi Service

Recently, a friend left his job, bought a car and registered to work for a taxi-hailing service provider...

In-Picture

Drop us a message

Or see contact page