Editorial | Nov 09,2024
The foreign exchange market remained notably stable last week, with only subtle fluctuations in the value of the Brewed Buck against the Green Buck. Banks maintained a uniform spread over the six days starting November 11, 2024, adhering to a two percent margin between buying and selling rates. The National Bank of Ethiopia's (NBE) firm regulation imposes uniformity, hoping to prevent excessive volatility during mounting economic pressures.
Governor Mamo Mihiretu's cautious position signalled his intent to manage expectations and discourage speculative activities that could fuel inflation. Gone are the days when banks engaged in cutthroat competition over widening spreads; the Central Bank's approach to discipline the industry seeks to prevent abrupt swings in the currency market.
However, some banks deviated from this pattern, revealing underlying dynamics in response to liquidity pressures. Notably, Dashen Bank posted the highest buying rate of 122.85 Br on November 15 and 16, nearly three Birr above the market average. Dashen Bank's executives were actively courting forex holders, possibly due to internal liquidity needs or in anticipation of increased foreign currency demand. By offering a more attractive rate, Dashen Bank may be targeting to beef up its foreign currency reserves.
In contrast, the state-owned Commercial Bank of Ethiopia (CBE) maintained the lowest buying rate at 119.2044 Br, positioning itself as a conservative force in the market. CBE's traditionally cautious approach indicates a strategy that prioritises stability over aggressive expansion.
The average buying rate among banks hovered around 120.64 Br to the dollar, while the selling rate averaged 123.25 Br. Selling rates also varied, with the Central Bank's weighted average inching upward from 122.2 Br on November 11 to 122.7 Br five days later. These subtle adjustments unveiled the Central Bank's acknowledgement of the Birr's depreciating pressure without triggering an alarm or fueling inflationary expectations.
Private banks such as the Cooperative Bank of Oromia (Coop Bank) and Wegagen Bank posted elevated selling rates, reaching 124 Br and 125.3 Br, respectively, on November 15 and 16. These higher rates may reflect attempts to counterbalance increased buying prices, indicating liquidity constraints or a strategy to capitalise on heightened demand for foreign currency. Other banks, like Zemen Bank, held steady with lower selling rates, reinforcing their roles as conservative players capable of sustaining narrower spreads without losing market share.
In the high-stakes world of foreign exchange, banks reveal their strategic playbooks through the buying and selling rates they post each day. An analysis of recent data uncovered a clear pattern. They clustered into distinct categories based on shared behaviours in setting these rates, signalling divergent approaches in a fiercely competitive market. At the centre of this segmentation lies the average buying rate of 120.80 Br and an average selling rate of 123.17 Br. Yet, not all banks fit into these benchmarks. Some consistently undercut the averages, while others push their rates higher, uncovering differing priorities and strategies.
Banks like Goh Betoch (GBE), Tsehay (TES), Gadaa (GAD) banks, and CBE consistently posted buying rates below the average. Goh's buying rate stood at 119.0210 Br, and Gadaa's at 119 Br, both quite lower than the mean. On the selling side, these banks again offered rates beneath the average: Goh at 121.4 Br and Gadaa at 121.39 Br. These banks may appeal to businesses with long-term foreign exchange needs by offering lower buying and selling rates, such as importers seeking cost-effective currency purchasing.
Others like Wegagen (WEG), Dashen (DAS), and Amhara (AMH) banks regularly posted rates above the average. Wegagen's buying rate was 122.85 Br, while its selling rate reached 125.3 Br. Dashen closely followed with a buying rate of 122.85 Br and a selling rate of 125.3076 Br. These banks appear to be adopting an aggressive posture, possibly wanting to attract clients willing to pay a premium for expedited services or specialised financial products. Their higher rates might reflect confidence in their market positioning or a strategic move to boost forex inflows under competitive pressures.
Some banks, notably Tsehay, exhibited noteworthy daily rate fluctuations. Its buying rates varied between 119.2 Br and 119.2 Br, and its selling rates fluctuated from 121.6 Br to 121.6 Br. Such volatility could indicate a dynamic pricing strategy, likely responding swiftly to market conditions or attempting to optimise gains in a rapidly changing forex environment. These divergent behaviours represent underlying strategic choices.
Banks posting lower rates might prioritise stability and long-term client relationships, containing risks associated with market volatility. Those with higher rates could be leveraging their market positions to maximise profits, accepting greater risk for potentially higher returns. Banks with volatile rates may engage in active market responsiveness, adjusting rates to reflect real-time supply and demand dynamics. This approach might attract clients looking for the best possible rates at any given moment but could deter those seeking consistency.
These strategies influence the market itself. Banks with aggressive rate policies can shift competitive dynamics, prompting others to adjust their rates or risk losing market share. Those adopting a conservative approach contribute to market stability but might miss opportunities presented by favourable market movements.
The Brewed Buck is expected to continue its gradual depreciation in late November. The persistent forex scarcity exerts pressure on the currency. However, the pace of depreciation is likely to remain measured, contingent on the Central Bank's oversight and targeted interventions. Without a broader liquidity response, where the Central Bank could deploy its firepower, these pressures could lead to more pronounced divergences among banks.
In the absence of unexpected developments, the average buying rate could edge closer to 121 Br, while the selling rate may approach 124 Br by month's end. This forecast considers the seasonal patterns as the market enters a period of heightened import activities, increasing demand for foreign currency. Select banks might adopt aggressive pricing to attract scarce foreign currency, intensifying competition and disrupting the equilibrium.
PUBLISHED ON
Nov 16,2024 [ VOL
25 , NO
1281]
Editorial | Nov 09,2024
Agenda | Mar 02,2024
Radar | May 07,2022
Radar | Aug 22,2020
Fortune News | Jun 11,2024
Money Market Watch | Nov 09,2024
Viewpoints | Nov 05,2022
Fortune News | Mar 05,2022
Fortune News | Feb 22,2020
Radar | Oct 08,2022
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transportin...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
The cracks in Ethiopia's higher education system were laid bare during a synthesis re...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Construction authorities have unveiled a price adjustment implementation manual for s...
Dec 21 , 2024
The main avenues and thoroughfares of Addis Abeba have undergone an impressive faceli...
Dec 14 , 2024
Ethiopia's monetary policy has shifted conspicuously in recent years. Gone is the era...
Dec 7 , 2024
For decades the Ethiopian Petroleum Supply Enterprise (EPSE), a state-owned giant ent...
Nov 30 , 2024
In the corridors of government offices worldwide, the question of how much to pay mem...