Black Market Gold Rush

Sep 24 , 2022
By Christian Tesfaye

---

We have all heard the news by now. The black market rate for one dollar is now around 90 Br. The official rate, for those with access, is around 53 Br. This is a premium of over 70pc, unheard of as far as memory serves me.

Look at the Balance of Payments, and the reason why becomes clear. Despite rises in goods and service export, the four billion dollar escalation in goods’ import values, has put the balance position in negative territory. Thank global price rises in fuel, grains and edible oil for this. An official two billion dollars more in foreign currency rushed out of the country than was brought in.

Cepheus Growth Capital, an investment management firm, estimates that the foreign currency reserves of the central bank have fallen by nearly half to 1.5 billion dollars. Banks only have around one billion dollars in reserves. There has been massive drawdown to cover foreign currency expenses in goods import, debt service and a fall in both new borrowing and grants. It is a very precarious situation.

It is thus no surprise that the black market rates have gone up. It is simple supply and demand. More buyers of foreign currency – including car importers – unable to satisfy their foreign currency needs from commercial banks are taking their business to informal market players and willing to pay phenomenal premiums for the access. The joke here is that commercial banks themselves charge high fees to sell their non-existent foreign currency. The higher the demand, the larger the spread between the official and informal rates. The lifting of restrictions against franco valuta is also believed to feed this demand, as importers rush to buy dollars and euros.

On the supply side, a good chunk of the remittance is being diverted to the black market. Here again, supply and demand apply. Few members of the diaspora exchange their dollars at banks, which offer a measly 53 Br rate compared to widely available black market players that bid nearly double that amount. It is not a competition. The other joke here is that this happens under the nose of the authorities in a popular spot, National Theatre. It has been public knowledge for decades that it is the epi-centre of black market trading.

It seems that the government has a few plans against this. It is impossible to say to what extent the decision to liberalise the financial sector is influenced by the foreign currency shortage but it is most likely in the minds of policymakers. The government is also trying to get an International Monetary Fund (IMF) programme going. Beyond that, it is merely appealing to the good nature of the diaspora community to remit through formal channels, where the central bank buys 70pc at the prevailing market rate.

There will be no way out of this until productivity in Ethiopia improves in agriculture (to address food insecurity and reduce the need to import so much grain) and manufacturing (to diversify out of the volatile commodity market and exploit the country’s cheap labour). Until the merchandise trade deficit, currently at 14 billion dollars, or around 14pc of GDP, or more than three-fold of revenues from goods export, could be addressed, it is impossible to get anywhere.

The structural issue of the age-old foreign currency crisis also needs to be addressed: lack of a float. Unless the Birr can be exchanged at a market rate, economic slowdowns will always come with a foreign currency crisis. Of course, it is probably a good idea to improve the political situation and work out issues on debt burden with development partners first.

---

PUBLISHED ON Sep 24,2022 [ VOL 23 , NO 1169]

---