Jan 23 , 2021

The Ministry of Trade & Industry has ordered the cancellation of Muleg Oil Importer's trade name. The company has been in a dispute with Mullege Plc, the nation's fifth-largest coffee exporter, for three years over the trade name.

Signed by Amlework Mune, director of trade name registration at the Ministry, the letter that was sent to the city's trade bureau ordered the annulment of the oil importer's trade name. The cancellation was decreed following the company's failure to change its name after being given a month to do so.

Three months ago, the Ministry wrote a letter to Muleg Oil Importer notifying the company to change its name by citing that its similarity to Mullege could confuse or mislead consumers. The two companies' engagement in a similar business line is another reason the Ministry pointed to while ordering the company to change its name.

Before the Ministry gave the latest decision, the two companies went through a court battle over their trade names, which are pronounced almost the same way. The case was initiated three years ago after Mullege appealed to the Ministry, alleging that Muleg Oil had altered its trade name to be similar to Mullege, which was incepted in 1953 as a small coffee supplier and became an exporter in 1996.

The Ministry reviewed the case and gave an administrative decision to revoke the name of Muleg Oil Importer in March 2018. While passing the administrative decision, the Ministry reasoned that Mullege registered its trade name before the importer back in 2003. The Ministry also admitted that it made a mistake in granting the oil company its trade name.

The Ministry’s decision triggered the seven-year-old oil importer, Muleg, to take the case to Federal High Court. In its appeal filed at the end of March 2018, Muleg petitioned the court to reverse the Ministry’s decision. The oil importer stated that the two companies are different business entities and that the Ministry provided them with a license after checking that their trade names did not overlap.

Mullege, in its statement of defense, argued that since it obtained the license as a general importer, the company might also engage in the oil-importing business. Mullege additionally claimed that the two companies' trademarks are alike in the Amharic language, sharing the same three letters and phonetics.

The Ministry, who was a co-defendant under the case, stated that Mullege Plc could indeed engage in the petroleum import business and requested that the Court reject the oil importer's appeal.

After a year-long litigation, the High Court reversed the Ministry's ruling and stated that both companies could keep their trade names. In passing the verdict, the Court stressed that though their names seem identical, Muleg has registered as a petroleum and related products importer while Mullege was listed as a general import-export company.

Discontented with the lower court's ruling, Mullege and the Ministry took the case to the Federal Supreme Court by appealing that the lower court had made an error of law in passing the judgement. The duo petitioned the Supreme Court to reverse the lower court's ruling as it gave the judgement without considering whether the two companies' names sounded the same.

The Court passed its ruling without looking into the documentary evidence Mullege presented showing that the two companies engage in similar businesses, claimed Mullege’s appeal.

At the end of January last year, the Supreme Court remanded the case back to the Trade Ministry, reversing the High Court's decision. It also ordered that the Ministry make its decision based on whether the two companies are engaged in the same business or not.

Nine months after the Supreme Court ruling, the Ministry sent a letter to Muleg notifying the company to change its name within a month's time. Two months after the notification, the Ministry ordered for the cancellation of Muleg's trade name.

"The Ministry took the measure in accordance with what the Commercial Registration & Business Licensing Proclamation allows us," said Amlework.

However, Tsedale Mekuria, Mullege Plc's lawyer, argues that the Ministry's latest decision was overdue.

"It shouldn't take this long to give the final decision," she said. "The final decision was made after we made various appeals up to the Minister"

She also added that Mullege will file another civil claim against the company requiring compensation for the damage it sustained.

Representatives of Muleg Oil Importer were not immediately available for comment.

PUBLISHED ON Jan 23,2021 [ VOL 21 , NO 1082]

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Put your comments here

N.B: A submit button will appear once you fill out all the required fields.

Editors' Pick