Zemen Bank, a relatively young player in the banking industry, has once again punched above its weight.
A second-tier financial institution, it posted a net income of 2.5 billion Br for the 2023/24 fiscal year, ranking seventh among 28 private commercial banks. Its performance surpassed the industry's average net income of 1.9 billion Br. The Bank’s achievement is particularly notable given the intense concentration of profitability within a few top banks, which uncovers structural asymmetries in the banking industry.
The state-owned Commercial Bank of Ethiopia (CBE) leads, constituting 36pc of the industry's 58.36 billion Br net income posted by all banks except the Development Bank of Ethiopia (DBE).
Despite operating in the shadows of such financial behemoths, Zemen Bank’s executives have demonstrated strategic acumen. The Bank’s profit surged by 32pc over the previous year, netting 2.39 billion Br, outperforming generational peers like Berhan Bank, which recorded half that profit.
"Policies and directives by the central bank have had significant impacts on the banking business," said Enye Bemir, Zemen's board chairwoman. "But the minimum capital requirement helps to strengthen financial stability."
Zemen's paid-up capital increased by 49.1pc to 7.45 billion Br, bringing its capital adequacy ratio to 25.9pc. However, earnings per share (EPS) declined by 12.5pc to 376 Br – further sliding down from 430 Br a year ago - due to recapitalisation. Despite this, Zemen's share earnings (37.6pc) remain higher than the industry average of 31.6pc. Two years ago, the Bank had posted a 45.5pc EPS.
Though reflective of Zemen’s emphasis on capitalisation, according to the financial expert, the downward EPS trend with a 79 Br decline in two years may demand a review of its capital policy to align with shareholder expectations for returns.
Dereje disagreed. With plans to raise capital, he strongly believes that risk management should be at the core of bankers’ strategy for sustainability, responding to policy changes, and becoming competitive with foreign banks.
"Building strong capital is a priority," said Dereje.
Shareholders have resolved to raise capital to 15 billion Br, more than double the threshold the regulatory bank set for July 2026. Incorporated in 2008 with 2,800 shareholders, Zemen Bank began as a one-branch operation. Over the years, it has expanded to 128 branches and 1,800 staff.
The National Bank of Ethiopia's (NBE) regulatory measures to curb inflation — down to 19.9pc in June 2024 from 30.4pc the previous year — introduced operational difficulties like foreign exchange shortages and tightening monetary policy. Zemen Bank appears to have overcome these constraints by capitalising on lowering forex surrender, which provided opportunities to increase income from related services.
"Timely and proper use of available resources was key to achieving the results," said Zemen's President, Dereje Zebene. "Managing our credit portfolio and forex allocations were part of the strategy."
The London-based financial statement analyst Abdulmenan Mohammed (PhD) finds the expansion in interest income particularly striking, given the Central Bank's lending cap. He attributed Zemen Bank's likely adjustment of lending rates and focus on moderate credit expansion to offset regulatory restrictions.
Revenue growth at Zemen showed a robust 35.3pc rise during the year. Interest on loans, advances, and central bank bonds increased by 33.9pc to 5.35 billion Br, while fees and commission income rose by 49.5pc to 1.98 billion Br. Foreign exchange gains contributed an additional 319.1 million Br, marking an 18.3pc increase. These gains outpaced some first-generation banks, such as Dashen Bank. It registered forex gains of 129.34 million Br during the same period.
Zemen's cost structure also saw increases. Interest expenses rose by 25.3pc to 1.71 billion Br, and wage and operational expenses swelled by nearly half, reaching 1.42 billion Br and 1.02 billion Br, respectively. However, Zemen Bank is among the industry outliers for spending less on wages and administrative expenses than its interest expenses. So did the provision for loans and other assets impairment increase markedly by 87.7pc, reaching 266.03 million Br.
"Although the figure in absolute terms is reasonable, management should keep an eye on the growth rate of this expense," cautioned Abdulmenan.
Zemen’s President concurred, stating that the provision is meant to keep the Bank away from risk.
"It doesn't mean that all impaired loans were not paid," he said.
Dereje brings 25 years of experience from first-generation banks such as Wegagen and Awash banks. Under his watch, Zemen's total assets grew by 23.9pc to 59.2 billion Br. Its return on assets (RoA) is 4.47pc, surpassing the five-year average by 0.14 percentage points, while its return on equity (RoE) reached 27pc, 3.4 percentage points lower than the five-year average.
Total loans and advances increased by 13.5pc to 35.6 billion Br, while total deposits rose 43.6 billion Br, jumping by 17.6pc, bringing the Bank's loan-to-deposit ratio to a more conservative 74.8pc, down from 84.65pc a year earlier.
"The reduction aligns with the central bank's credit cap directive," Dereje told Fortune.
The Central Bank’s tight monetary policy drive, which caps loan growth at 14pc, has impacted commercial banks, restricting credit issuance and pulling down loan-deposit ratios across the banking industry. Zemen Bank also expanded its income-generating investments, with holdings in Treasury bills (T-bill), bonds, and other securities rising by 45pc to 5.24 billion Br.
"The reallocation demonstrates Zemen Bank's adaptability in offsetting income limitations imposed by the credit cap through strategic investment in secure and yield-generating assets," said Abdulmenan.
Cash and cash equivalents surged by 56.7pc to 13.96 billion Br, resulting in a higher liquidity-to-asset ratio of 23.6pc, up from 18.6pc. While this liquidity buffer helps stability, Abudelmenan urged that Zemen could benefit from redirecting some liquid resources toward higher-yielding investments.
Within the limited window, Zemen Bank made selective investments in the Ethiopian Securities Exchange (ESX), EthSwitch, and the insurance industry while upgrading IT systems and boosting human resource capacity.
One of the Bank's long-serving employees, Seble Tilahun, was a branch manager at Meskel Flower, primarily serving corporate clients. She believes her branch achieved commendable performance in deposits, foreign currency, and loans.
"Despite the industry-wide liquidity issues and policy changes, our Bank remained strong," Seble told Fortune. "Immediate actions were taken."
Shareholder and former board director Emana Getu (Prof.) expressed contentment with the Bank's performance in profits, forex management, and customer service.
"It’s outpaced its generational peers," he said.
He recommends the management revise long-term strategic plans to stay updated on changing trends.
"It's not business as usual anymore," Emana added.
Zemen Bank's latest report is consistent with its historical records. Two years ago, the Bank reported a 22.3pc profit increase, reaching 1.81 billion Br, outpacing the average profit of 15 private commercial banks by 400 million Br. Return on equity stood at 24.3pc, and return on assets at 4.3pc, both comfortably above industry averages of 19.8pc and 2.4pc, respectively.
While first-generation larger banks like Awash, Abyssinia, and Dashen continue to dominate in size and market share, Zemen Bank's achievements illustrated that smaller banks could compete effectively through operational efficiency and profitability.
“All things considered, we did really good,” Dereje told Fortune.
PUBLISHED ON
Nov 03,2024 [ VOL
25 , NO
1279]
Radar | Oct 27,2024
News Analysis | Oct 27,2024
Commentaries | Feb 18,2023
Fortune News | Jun 10,2023
Fortune News | Apr 10,2023
Fortune News | May 23,2020
Fortune News | Sep 03,2022
Fortune News | Sep 04,2021
Fortune News | Jul 13,2024
Radar | Nov 03,2024
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transportin...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
The cracks in Ethiopia's higher education system were laid bare during a synthesis re...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Construction authorities have unveiled a price adjustment implementation manual for s...
Nov 16 , 2024
In the realm of public finance, balance sheets speak louder than rhetoric. In such do...
Nov 9 , 2024
Ethiopia's foreign exchange debacle resembles a tangled web of contradictions and con...
Nov 2 , 2024
Addis Abeba, fondly dubbed a 'New Flower,' is wilting under the weight of unchecked u...
Oct 26 , 2024
When flames devoured parts of Mercato, residents watched helplessly as decades of toi...