May 18 , 2019
By TAMRAT G. GIORGIS ( FORTUNE STAFF WRITER )
The Development Bank of Ethiopia (DBE), the state-owned policy bank established to provide development financing, has suffered a mammoth loss of 1.7 billion Br from its operations during the first three-quarters of 2018/19. This is an amount never recorded in the history of the country's financial industry. The loss is comparable to the gross profits recorded two years ago by six private banks.
More than half of the loss was reported in the third quarter of this year, reaching 981.1 million Br, revealing that the Bank is in deep water and unable to recover massive loans it has been advancing. DBE's financial and performance report was released two weeks ago during a two-day meeting held inside the conference hall of the Ministry of Trade & Industry on Marshal Tito Road. The management board, under Haileyesus Bekele, described the Bank's performance as "satisfactory." It credited DBE's recovery of close to 1.6 billion Br of the 2.2 billion Br outstanding the bank had advanced in project and lease financing during the period.
A closer look at its books, however, shows a result that is all but encouraging, for the unprecedented loss is attributed to provisions held to secure bad loans and advances, amounting to 17 billion Br.
At 109 years old, the oldest bank in the country has reported a mixed bag of results in its performance in mobilising resources using its 107 branches and 13 regional offices. Although its total income of a little over four billion Birr showed a modest increase of 10pc, the resources it has mobilised from interest on loans and advances registered a 10pc drop to 2.7 billion Br, owing to political uncertainty in the country and a slowing down in business. Run by a president, five vice presidents and 26 directors, DBE has disbursed 1.8 billion Br of the three billion Br it was prepared to advance over the past nine months to sectors it says are priorities: commercial agriculture, agro-processing, manufacturing, mining and extractive industries.
Over the years, commercial farms clustered mainly in the Gambella and Benishangul Gumuz regional states and flower farms, as well as textile, steel and cable manufacturing plants owned by Ethiopians, Turkish, Indian and Chinese companies were the most significant clients of DBE. Their records in serving their debts have not been positive, a judgement based on non-performing loans that represent 38.5pc of its total loans and advances. DBE was compelled to put aside 3.5 billion Br as a provision in the three quarters, 1.2 times larger than what its executives had planned. It is also an amount that consumed the Bank's operating income of 1.8 billion Br.
Experts see DBE's mounting non-performing loans (NPLs) could be behind the Bank's caution in its lending drive this year, judging by the decline in income and earned interest. Losses on this front were compensated by increases in income from treasury bills, up by 163pc to 760.1 million Br; and a 46pc increase in service charges to 263.39 million Br. However, the most substantial increase of 464pc was reported from foreign exchange fluctuations that reached 252.6 million Br.
This has not come without a cost. DBE's operating expenses have gone up by 46pc to 2.2 billion Br due to a 68pc increase in interest and charges, 1.7 billion Br in total. Financial analysts see the Bank's performance in capital, assets, management, equity and liquidity - CAMEL, in the industry parlance - as dismal. It has led to a significant decline if measured by a return on assets ratio of negative 2.19pc, missing its target of 0.33pc for the fiscal year 2018/19.
“The main reason for this underachievement is the decline in net profit due to the huge amount of loan loss provisions accounted for non-performing loans,” the Bank's management admits in its report.
Neither is the prospect for the full year positive, according to experts who examined DBE's balance sheet.
“The uncertain political and economic conditions in the country, coupled with the massive level of NPLs may increase the size of the loss in the quarter to come,” warns a financial analyst based in London. “Worsening loss may put DBE in serious financial trouble unless the government steps in.”
DBE's board of directors, chaired by Tegegneworq Gettu, a retired UN senior staffer, has placed a request to the government to inject fresh capital of seven billion Br, according to people knowledgable of the Bank. Others see no redemption for DBE. They urge the government to liquidate the Bank or change its business model to commercial banking.
"DBE needs to be dissolved if the government needs development," says a person whose job is working closely with banks. "It is better off starting up a new one."
DBE officials were not available for comment.
PUBLISHED ON May 18,2019 [ VOL 20 , NO 994]
Radar | Feb 16,2019
Radar | Feb 15,2020
Radar | Jan 11,2020
Sunday with Eden | Dec 14,2019
Radar | Dec 25,2018
Radar | Jun 27,2020
Fortune News | Mar 30,2019
Fortune News | Feb 01,2020
Radar | Jul 13,2020
August 8 , 2020 . By MAYA MISIKIR
On any day, the waiting hall of Black Lion Hospital is not a sight for the faint-hearted. Patients seeking treatment find themselves maroone...
August 8 , 2020 . By MAYA MISIKIR
Shemsu Hussien was transported in an ambulance from his hometown in Worabe, Silte Zone to Addis Abeba whi...
August 8 , 2020
A familiar sight these days is high government officials - the very important people - hunched over muddy...
August 8 , 2020 . By Atsebaha Abay
There are currently a number of initiatives that are mobilising large sums of money to address different...
Getachew Reda, the increasingly combative spin doctor of the Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF), says he is no longer optimistic about...
After they made a portentous decision last week in passing a resolution at the House of Federation where...
August 8 , 2020
A familiar sight these days is high government officials - the very important people...
August 1 , 2020
Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) had an audience with leaders of the opposition bloc ...
July 25 , 2020
The economic indicators for Ethiopia this fiscal year are less than encouraging, even...
July 18 , 2020
In the past two years, it was perhaps the events of the first week of this month that...
Aneighbour recently gave birth to a baby girl. As tradition dictates, I went to visit her, bearing diapers and baby clothing. It was her sec...
Or see contact page