Feb 22 , 2020
By DIBORA SAMSON ( FORTUNE STAFF WRITER )
Mullege Plc and Muleg Oil have been fighting over their trade names.
The Federal Supreme Court remanded the trade name battle between a leading coffee exporter and an oil importer to the Ministry of Trade & Industry for an administrative verdict.
Mullege Plc, the leading coffee exporter, has been in a court battle with Muleg Oil Importer for the past two years over their trade names, which are pronounced almost the same way. The Federal High Court ruled both can use their name, which led the case to reach the Supreme Court.
The appellate court, which presided over the case for almost a year, sent the case back to the Ministry, reversing the High Court's ruling.
The case began when Mullege appealed to the Ministry, alleging that Muleg Oil Importer had altered its trade name to be similar to Mullege. After reviewing the claim, the Ministry gave an administrative decision in revoking the name of Muleg Oil Importer on March 23, 2018.
The Ministry reasoned that Mullege had established and registered its trade name before the importer in 2003.
In response, Muleg, the six-year-old oil importer, took the case to Federal High Court on March 30, 2018, requesting a reversal of the ruling. On its claim, the oil importer stated that the two companies are different business entities, and the Ministry provided them with a license after checking that their trade name did not overlap.
In its defence, Mullege claimed that since it obtained the license as a general importer, it might also involve itself in the oil-importing business. Mullege's lawyer also argued that the names of the two companies are identical in the Amharic language, sharing the same three letters and sound.
The Ministry, which was a co-defendant, stated that Mullege Plc could engage in the petroleum import business and requested that the Court reject the appeal of the oil importer.
After reviewing the case, the High Court reversed the ruling of the Ministry on April 14, 2019, ordering that both companies could keep their trade names.
Though their name seems identical, Muleg has registered its trade name as a petroleum and related products importer. In contrast, Mullege registered its trade name as a general importer and exporter company, reads the High Court's ruling.
Opposing the lower court's ruling, Mullege Plc and the Ministry took the case to the Supreme Court by appealing that the lower court had made an error of law in passing the verdict. The duo requested that the Supreme Court reverse the ruling of the High Court, stating that it gave the judgement without considering whether the names of the two companies sounded the same.
The appeal also reads that Mullege Plc has presented documentary evidence to the High Court showing that the two companies engage in similar businesses; however, the Court passed its ruling without looking into them.
After examining the case, the Supreme Court - presided over by justices Reta Tolossa, Endashaw Adane and Abeba Embibel - passed the ruling on January 30, 2020, remanding the case back to the Trade Ministry, reversing the decision given by the High Court.
The Supreme Court ordered that the Ministry make its decision based on whether the two companies are engaged in the same business or not.
“We agree with the decision of the Supreme Court," said Tsedale Mekuria, lawyer of Mullege Plc. “But, rather than referring the case back to the Ministry, the [C]ourt can sustain the Ministry's decision since it already passed a ruling on the case two years back.”
Elsa Seyoum, the legal representative of the Ministry, and managers of Muleg declined to comment on the issue.
PUBLISHED ON Feb 22,2020 [ VOL 20 , NO 1034]
Fortune News | Apr 13,2019
Radar | Oct 24,2020
Radar | Nov 07,2020
Fortune News | Dec 28,2019
Agenda | Oct 12,2019
Commentaries | Apr 25,2020
Editorial | Apr 09,2022
Radar | Jun 29,2019
Fortune News | Feb 20,2021
Fortune News | Dec 04,2022
Jul 2 , 2022 . By RUTH TAYE
On a rainy afternoon last week, a coffee processing facility in the capital's Akaki-Qality District was abuzz with activ...
Nov 27 , 2021
Against my will, I have witnessed the most terrible defeat of reason and the most sa...
Nov 13 , 2021
Plans and reality do not always gel. They rarely do in a fast-moving world. Every act...
Oct 16 , 2021 . By HAWI DADHI
Residing in a country with no capital market, an organised marketplace for trading se...
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country's most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or two...
Dec 4 , 2022
Last week saw enraged university lecturers' threatening to stage a strike. They addre...
Nov 26 , 2022
In the wake of the liberalization of the telecom sector, Ethiopian authorities have m...
Nov 19 , 2022
The rounds of talks to end wars in Ethiopia held in Pretoria, South Africa, and Nairo...
Nov 12 , 2022
Two weeks have passed since negotiators from Ethiopia's federal government and the TP...
What are the odds of seeing a housemaid who loves the job dearly and wakes up every morning to do the chores with excitement? Well, this...
Or see contact page