Fortune News | Dec 10,2022
Jul 8 , 2023
By BEMNET TAFESSE ( FORTUNE STAFF WRITER. )
A circular that prevents the dismissal of appeals presented before higher courts without adequate justification has been signed by Chief Justice Tewodros Mihret a month ago.
The working practice used to give judges the right to concur with rulings of the lower courts by merely filling out a form.
It came about with hopes of avoiding redundancy and was handy when the applicant bases the appeal entirely on the record of the original hearing and does not request permission to call in new evidence. However, the absence of regulatory mechanisms led the scheme to be abused in discarding applications even with updated evidence.
Officials disclosed the new requirement came about following the continued grievances by appellants on the discipline and integrity of the judicial system.
Aron Degol, research & legal affairs director at the Supreme Court, said adequate reason must be given with each decision in a manner that ensures accountability. He expressed that while dismissing cases by filing out forms may reduce the courts' caseload, it significantly eroded belief in the judicial system.
"The growing number of applications brought before the disciplinary committee shows the level of dissatisfaction from the public," said Aron.
The circular reasons that dismissing motioned files by merely aligning with lower courts' rationale is tantamount to depriving the right to appeal, which is guaranteed under the constitution.
Legal practitioners applaud the development as a sensible step taken by the supreme court to restore faith in the judicial system and bring accountability.
Wendimu Alemu, a legal practitioner with over five years of experience, observed that the prior scheme was often prone to abuses giving free rein to dismiss applications. He claims to have encountered such instances in his own cases, leaving him confused as to the reason behind the rulings.
"It's difficult to know whether the applications have been looked at or not," he told Fortune.
He claims that such practices contribute to jeopardizing the accountability of judges and the very essence of rationality that need to be upheld in courts.
Nearly 400 judges are working in 25 federal courts comprised of the Federal First Instance, the Federal High, the Supreme courts, and the newly established Trade & Investment courts. In the first eight months of this fiscal year, the Federal Supreme Court has dismissed 8,970 cases in its three inquisitorial benches by merely filling out forms.
Fikadu Solomon who was in corporate litigation at the Federal High Court in 2021, claims to have been wronged by the practice. He paid two million Birr to the respondent for the construction of canals for his farm. However, Fikadu claims the respondent failed to perform in line with the contractual obligation with the case ending up before the First Instance Court.
After one and a half years, a ruling was made in favour of the respondent citing that the construction work has been carried out according to the contractual agreement. Aggrieved by this decision Fikadu file his motioned petition to the Federal High Court incorporating evidence that can substantiate his claim. However, the appeal was dismissed without considering the newly introduced evidence.
"No one even gave me a reason," he said.
A judge at the Federal High Court presides over an average of 203 cases a year, according to a World Bank Study. The number is higher when it is juxtaposed with other African countries, such as South Africa with over 145 cases annually.
Hefty case loads and tight schedules are cited as the prominent reason for case backlogs amongst experts.
Fasil Wondwossen, a law school lecturer at Haramaya University, attributes the rise in complaints to be caused by a serious shortage of manpower which prevents judges from thoroughly going through each case.
Despite the instrumental nature of the circular, Fasil questions its validity if courts still grapple with issues related to human power. He reasons that even if the new circular is in operation, the quality is at risk without the addition of personnel to the system.
"Losing balance between quick and quality is the source of the problem," said Fasil.
PUBLISHED ON Jul 08,2023 [ VOL 24 , NO 1210]
Fortune News | Dec 10,2022
View From Arada | Jun 01,2019
Radar | Nov 20,2023
Editorial | Dec 17,2022
Fortune News | Jan 28,2023
Sunday with Eden | Aug 29,2020
My Opinion | Jun 27,2020
Sunday with Eden | Nov 30,2019
Editorial | Dec 10,2022
Dec 24 , 2022
Biniam Mikru heads the department of cabinet affairs under Mayor Adanech Abiebie. But...
Jul 2 , 2022 . By RUTH TAYE
On a rainy afternoon last week, a coffee processing facility in the capital's Akaki-Qality District was abuzz with activ...
Nov 27 , 2021
Against my will, I have witnessed the most terrible defeat of reason and the most sa...
Nov 13 , 2021
Plans and reality do not always gel. They rarely do in a fast-moving world. Every act...
Leaders of the National Election Board are in a charm offensive mood, of a sort. Last week, they organised a rare tour for members of the me...
When the country's most senior diplomats and envoys return back to their posts after two-week debriefings, they leave behind a point or two...
Dec 2 , 2023
The symphony of traffic noise in Addis Abeba is not just a sign of life, but a siren...
Nov 25 , 2023
Ethiopia's quest to develop a functioning capital market is a demanding yet not unach...
Nov 18 , 2023
Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed (PhD) has made a fervent call for landlocked Ethiopia to ga...
Nov 11 , 2023
In November last year, a ray of hope pierced the gloomy skies of Ethiopia as the Pret...
I have a love-hate relationship with my phone. It is my go to source for information. I enjoy interacting with text messages and browsing t...
Over the weekend, I attended a wedding where my husband was one of the protocols. Despite the typical joy...
Or see contact page