Radar | Oct 20,2024
Last week, a soap and detergent manufacturer was in the middle of finalising a seven million Birr import payment for chemicals, mandatory input for his production. On July 29, 2024, he was hit with jaw-dropping, gut-wrenching news. The federal government has dropped a bombshell strategy of allowing market forces of supply and demand to determine the foreign exchange rates. Poof, a four million Birr loss overnight.
“I was in shock!” said the general manager, who opted for anonymity.
According to him, the detergent industry already suffers from security issues which have hampered market access.
“It feels like a final nail in the coffin,” he told Fortune.
With the unprecedented shipping costs and increased customs duties based on the inflated import payments, the general manager anticipates further cost escalation.
"Obviously, I'll add it to the final price," he told Fortune.
The first week following the National Bank of Ethiopia’s (NBE) bold decision to float the currency was tough for business owners. Those in the middle of transactions lost millions. While the supply and demand seem to have frozen wabbling in uncertainty. The directive introduced major changes to Ethiopia’s foreign exchange regulations through the new Foreign Exchange Directive.
Floating the currency is a remedy, not a new economic structure.
According to Fikadu Degafe, vice governor of the central bank, these reforms aim to address currency shortages, promote economic growth, and create a more competitive and transparent foreign exchange market. He said the adoption of a market-based monetary policy is an essential step towards addressing long-standing macroeconomic constraints.
The central bank's three-year strategy aims to achieve robust macroeconomic stability through quantitative goals, such as increasing foreign currency reserves and maintaining an exchange rate that avoids major discrepancies with the parallel market. The most notable change is allowing banks to buy and sell foreign currencies at freely negotiated rates, with the NBE intervening only to prevent market disorder.
For Tewodros Mekonnen (PhD), a macroeconomist, the move is a long-awaited measure to address 15 years of market distortions and macroeconomic instability.
"Floating the currency is a remedy, not a new economic structure," he told Fortune.
He noted that the previous plans led to exchange rate distortions, balance-of-payments problems, and depleted foreign reserves. However, Tewodros expected short-term economic pain, particularly inflation.
Tewodros also emphasised the importance of peace and security, alongside critical infrastructure investments. He urged the government to invest loans effectively in infrastructure, human capital, education, and health. Long-term solutions, he noted, would require monetary tightening and fiscal discipline to prevent issues like undisciplined money printing by the National Bank, which has contributed to exchange rate, balance of payments, and inflation problems.
“The reform is a necessary condition, not a sufficient one,” he said.
The directive abolished the priority list system for foreign currency allocation, which prioritised essential goods. Instead, it ensures foreign exchange is available on demand, simplifying access for importers and fostering a more equitable and transparent system.
In his briefing last week, Central Bank Governor Mamo Mihretu disclosed that the flight of economic activity to the black market—with adverse consequences such as tax evasion and loss of economic control—necessitated policy measures allowing the market to determine the exchange rate directly. He predicts that the policy will attract substantial foreign exchange inflows and investments while offering more autonomy to exporters in managing their foreign exchange income.
While Mamo lauded the new policy as beneficial for exporters, exporters report price surges for commodities, sending shockwaves through the market.
According to Yihunew Demelash, general manager of Maraki Trading Plc, coffee, oilseed, and pulses prices have surged in the past few days, complicating their export plans. Yihunew observed the price of coffee increasing by 300 Br in the week. He claims that suppliers have resorted to hoarding the commodities.
He said: "Suppliers are hoarding commodities, affecting our ability to export."
His company supplies over 60 containers of coffee, sesame, and soybean commodities to international markets in China, Israel, Europe, and Saudi Arabia. Prices for Sesame, the third most exported commodity have seen a surge of domestic prices by 3,000 Br, within the week following the currency float. Yihunew said domestic market stabilisation is essential for creating a beneficial environment for exporters. However, the new trend does not present clear benefits for them.
According to Yihunew, international buyers have also backtracked on their decisions during the week, demanding price renegotiations.
"It's a scary time for exporters," he said.
In contrast, Gizat Worqu, a leading coffee export business figure and general manager of the Ethiopian Coffee Association, sees the benefit. He noted that exporters have been forced to sell commodities at a loss, while others have been discouraged from participating.
Despite various policies over the decades, Ethiopian coffee exports have hovered around a billion dollars, reaching an all-time high last year of 1.43 billion dollars from 298,000tns. Gizat anticipates that over 300 million dollars have been lost due to the mismatch of international prices with domestic prices. He believes that currency float is a step forward to encourage exports and increase foreign currency inflows.
"This is an encouraging move albeit its uncertainity," he said.
He added that there are underlying issues that could lead exporters to engage in illicit activities, exacerbating the import and export deficit.
Both exporters suggest deeper structural issues need addressing. Gizat mentioned that coffee exports require a structural revamp to handle fluctuating demand, supply, and domestic economic shocks. He doubts whether the investment will be attracted to the country under the current conditions.
The macroeconomic policy change aims to stabilize the currency and continue negotiations to open Ethiopia's market gate to foreign capital at a critical time for enhancing investment. Authorities believe this measure will augment Ethiopia's economic competitiveness, unlock export potential, and pull in foreign direct investment (FDI), with broader implications for investors.
Governor Mamo identified plans to expand foreign currency revenues through increased export revenues and import substitution, while manufacturers struggle with macroeconomic effects and low output facing closure. Zooming in, manufacturers paint a different picture.
The Ethiopian Oil Manufacturers Association attributed recent price hikes to new tax levies. Board chairman Mohammed Yusuf recalled appealing to the Ministry of Finance for exemptions from duty and customs taxes but received no solution.
"Prices are bound to rise," he said.
Most manufacturers have held off disbursing their products to the market since the new policy adjustments to observe market changes. He revealed that sourcing local products has become difficult in recent days. He sees potential in the manufacturing sector. However, Mohammed highlighted underlying problems preventing manufacturers from thriving: cumbersome customs duties on raw materials and recent VAT amendments.
Bankers weighed in their comments. They were part of the discussion late last week with insurers and regional state leaders where the Prime Minister explained the macroeconomic reforms.
Worku Lemma, a senior banker, said commercial banks are revising their exchange rates based on cash supply and foreign currency demand while monitoring liquidity reserves. "They are also eyeing tightrope competition," he said.
However, local liquidity remains a concern. While banks might borrow from the central bank reserve or another inter-banking mechanism, Worku emphasised the importance of managing liability risks.
"Banks should know how to properly manage their liquidity," he advised.
He noted that hoarding and price surges among traders are disrupting the market. He suggested that banks should have access to short-term forex liquidity to import essential commodities and stabilise the market.
"Traders will disrupt the market," he said.
Since last week, the exchange rate has seen a substantial rise eyeing a 100 Br mark. Ermias Tegera, president of Birhan Bank, acknowledged the attractive opportunities but raised concerns about the impact on assets and liabilities. He emphasised the need for a thorough macroeconomic analysis and proper forex management and structural organisation.
"We are all new to this," he said.
He noted that an underlying foreign currency shortage has increased forex commitments, burdening banks as they respond to market supply. Foreign currency flow must align with bank liquidity for resource mobilization and forex management to maintain healthy liquidity levels. Birhan Bank's asset quality, liquidity, and profitability are crucial for success, but profitability ratios, capital adequacy, and income balance with expenses reveal their moderate position. In 2022/23, the Bank registered a notable increase in its assets portfolio, with a 36.3pc rise to 45.05 billion Br.
Eshetu Fantaye, a veteran banker, has long advocated for forex liberalisation to preserve the value Birr has lost for many years. However, among the options, he would have the option of the partial foreign currency auctioning regime. Eshetu argues that the economy has been stifled by a chronic foreign currency shortage, hindering its ability to participate in the global economy. He describes the previous foreign exchange market as "aggressive" and believes a complete overhaul is necessary to eliminate the black market, strengthen the official channel, and align policies with currency demand.
He contends that forex liberalisation will prevent the government from excessive lending, and estimates the central bank has accumulated a reserve equivalent to four months of imports, or approximately 4.5 billion dollars for three quarters. While acknowledging the central bank's conservative reserve target, Eshetu believes it is grounded in sound economic analysis.
Liquidity management remains a critical challenge in stabilising exchange rates, especially given the pent-up demand for foreign currency, particularly in the manufacturing sector. Eshetu emphasises the need for careful planning to accommodate this demand.
To prevent abuses in the banking system, he calls on the central bank to crack down on commercial banks engaging in unfair practices and to ensure the foreign exchange market is not dominated by a few large banks.
"Implementing a real-time online foreign exchange and liquidity management system is recommended," he told Fortune.
PUBLISHED ON
Aug 04,2024 [ VOL
25 , NO
1266]
Radar | Oct 20,2024
Featured | Dec 29,2018
News Analysis | May 18,2024
Commentaries | Aug 25,2024
Radar | Mar 02,2024
Radar | Nov 27,2023
Radar | Feb 03,2024
Commentaries | Oct 03,2024
Radar | Oct 27,2024
Radar | Jul 17,2022
Aug 18 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Although predictable Yonas Zerihun's job in the ride-hailing service is not immune to...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Investors who rely on tractors, trucks, and field vehicles for commuting, transportin...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By MUNIR SHEMSU
The cracks in Ethiopia's higher education system were laid bare during a synthesis re...
Jul 13 , 2024 . By AKSAH ITALO
Construction authorities have unveiled a price adjustment implementation manual for s...
Nov 30 , 2024
In the corridors of government offices worldwide, the question of how much to pay mem...
Nov 23 , 2024
The fiscal puzzle deepens as the Council of Ministers approved a supplementary budget...
Nov 16 , 2024
In the realm of public finance, balance sheets speak louder than rhetoric. In such do...
Nov 9 , 2024
Ethiopia's foreign exchange debacle resembles a tangled web of contradictions and con...